Best American Restaurants in Coral Bay

Perfect, delicious, exceptional, done right, food that's cooked to perfection, and a service-orientated staff!!

Malik our waiter was gracious , menu knowledge was spot on and his service was great! Ambience of the bay 5 stars Highly recommend Jim york

When we checked in for our reservation at 11:26, a seemingly disgruntled hostess told us they don’t serve lunch until 11:30 so we walked through the shop and checked out the waterfront. When we came back at 11:30, the same hostess sat two or three walk in tables before us. When seated, we originally waited for service with no one coming to our table until Tim picked up our table and was very kind and hospitable. He understood we had been waiting for service and was responsive to our time limits due to a booked excursion. The food was fast and he brought our bill in anticipation of our quick departure. The food was overall good and we enjoyed the drinks and atmosphere!

Incredible food, ambiance and service! Super cool owners!

Having stayed at their sister property in Martha's Vineyard a few months earlier we had to come over for a meal while celebrating a return anniversary in St. Thomas. Everyone, from the ferry crew to the resort staff could not have been friendly and, more so, fully efficient and competent. Saturday nights the resort's upscale restaurant is closed and instead there is a much more casual offering. It is, however, no less terrific I'm certain and for our evening, just perfect. The evening was a very special one thanks to the associates and team members, chef especially.