Best American Restaurants in Nashotah

We had a fantastic experience at The Inn - Hartland for our anniversary! Despite making a last-minute reservation, we were warmly welcomed. The main courses were absolutely delicious, and we couldn't resist adding the fries and focaccia after seeing them delivered to a neighboring table — they were just as fantastic. The food was top-notch, and the friendly staff made the evening even more enjoyable with great conversation. Plus, the value for the price was impressive. Highly recommend this gem for anyone looking for great food and a welcoming atmosphere!

We chose this place as our week-late Valentine's dinner after seeing the striking photos of the dining room on their website! This beautiful restaurant featured shared plates, meaning that anywhere from 3-5 plates would be apppropriate for a party of 2. We ordered the beet salad, the black bass, and rib tacos, and they were all amazing. These 3 plates were just the right amount for us, although I didn't finish the last 2 bites of one of my tacos as I wanted to save room for dessert! We shared the cheesecake mousse dome and it was delightful!! The service was superb! Our waiter was friendly and knowledgable and made our dinner date just wonderful! We will be back for another special dinner occaision!

What a beautiful restaurant. Everything was delicious and so well thought through. The service was impeccable. I have to eat gluten free due to celiac disease and the service was so knowledgeable and made me feel cared for. It was a lovely night. We will be back.

This was our first time at Red Circle, Inn and it did not disappoint! We wanted to treat our friend to a special evening out. Creating fun, memories and laughs during a difficult time in her life. The Red Circle staff and our waitress Heather, understood the assignment. They were incredibly attentive, offered great suggestions off the menu, answered all our questions, even the ones regarding ingredients in each of the cocktails and took extra time to give us a tour when we were finished with our meal. Ask for Heather when you make reservations. She and the General Manager were amazing!

For wine tasting I had Rick and Annette. Both servers were very excellent but Rick stood out the most telling us the back story of every wine we tasted. Then we had dinner and Caiden was great at meeting our needs.