Best American Restaurants in Shirley

We got lucky with parking, that is the biggest hurdle. We had a reservation and got there a little early. They seated us exactly the time of our reservation. The wait staff was friendly and helpful. All the food was amazing. Definitely would go back.

I've been to over 50 Brazillian restaurants and this one is by far the best. Food was fresh, cooked to perfection, service was impeccable, and the timing of the meats and appetizers were on point! We were able to enjoy each thing that came to our table and not feeling overwhelmed with having too much on our plates. The drinks were fantastic too!!! I highly recommend this to everyone!

Always a great experience at "The Forge". Service is excellent, drinks are great, food is terrific, ambiance is wonderful. Highly recommend trying some of the appetizers as well as some of the signature cocktail drinks. The main courses are always wonderful - you don't make a mistake with any of them. It's also the only place where we always have dessert - they are creative and wonderful. Enjoy!

From the moment we were welcomed to the pleasant "seen you again soon" upon departing, everything was great. The server was pleasant and attentive without being bothersome. The flatbread dishes were tasty and cooked just right. The salad was fresh and the sandwich had just the right balance of flavorful content and bread. All were nicely presented. We are four, long-time friends who find Rail Trail the perfect venue to catch-up with one another.

Courteous service and good food for group of 5. Refills on iced tea and soda were prompt, server double-checked the order, and food was delicious. Garden Bahn Mi, couple Tavern burgers, Steak and cheese melt, and Mac and Cheese.