Best American Restaurants in Sussex

14 restaurants available nearby

1. North Star American Bistro-Brookfield

4.7

Exceptional(1926)

Price: Moderate

• American • Brookfield

Booked 31 times today

North Star is open for dine in! You can feel confident knowing that we are following guidelines set forth by the CDC, WRA, and the WEDC to ensure your dining experience is safe and healthy. We are still offering take out and curbside service if you are not ready to dine in! We encourage making reservations as this will help us maintain our social distancing within the restaurant. Thank you for the support you have shown and continue to show! We are excited to welcome you back.

2. Butler Inn

4.2

Awesome(13)

Price: Moderate

• American • Pewaukee

Booked 9 times today

At Butler Inn of Pewaukee, located by the serene Pewaukee Lake, seafood lovers can indulge in a culinary experience that stands out for its authenticity and quality. For over 36 years, this charming spot has been a favorite, celebrated for dishes like the perfectly cooked Walleye and the exquisite scallops. Patrons rave about the seafood offerings, noting the "mouth-watering, melt in your mouth filet" and lobsters that are "done to perfection." With glowing reviews like "The scallops were very good! And the saganaki was amazing!!", it's clear why Butler Inn is a beacon for seafood enthusiasts. Whether it’s for a casual outing or a special occasion, the combination of delicious seafood, attentive service, and a warm atmosphere makes Butler Inn a must-visit for anyone craving the true flavors of the sea.

A photo of Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant - Brookfield, WI restaurant

3. Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant - Brookfield, WI

4.7

Exceptional(7136)

Price: Moderate

• American • Brookfield

Booked 166 times today

At Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant in Brookfield, the wine bar experience is elevated to an art form. Celebrated for its "award-winning wines" and "Napa-style tasting rooms," this destination offers a perfect blend of ambiance and exquisite varietals that captivate both the novice and the connoisseur. Guests rave about the "lux wine tasting" where knowledgeable servers like Michael and Bella enhance the experience with their expertise. The wine selections are perfectly paired with dishes that highlight contemporary American cuisine with a twist of international flavors, ensuring a "wonderful dinner" that leaves an impression. Whether it's for a casual visit or a special occasion, Cooper's Hawk stands out as a top-tier Wine Bar, consistently providing "excellent service" and a memorable dining experience.

A photo of The Commodore - A Bartolotta Restaurant restaurant

4. The Commodore - A Bartolotta Restaurant

4.5

Awesome(273)

Price: Expensive

• American • Hartland

Booked 62 times today

Located on the shores of Nagawicka Lake, The Commodore – A Bartolotta Restaurant will be a unique, expansive destination dedicated to the legacy of Lake Country and thoughtfully reimagined to include a remarkable suite of dining and event experiences.

A photo of Dave & Buster's - Wauwatosa restaurant

5. Dave & Buster's - Wauwatosa

3.5

Very Good(72)

Price: Moderate

• American • Wauwatosa

Booked 27 times today

Each Dave & Buster's has more state-of-the-art games than ever, more mouth-watering menu items and the most innovative drinks anywhere. From wings to steaks, we've got whatever suits your appetite and our premium bar assures we're stocked to satisfy! Plus, you can watch your game on one of our massive HDTVs with epic stadium sound.

6. Eldr + Rime

4.5

Awesome(789)

Price: Expensive

• American • Wauwatosa

Booked 33 times today

Eldr + Rime in Wauwatosa, heralded as the "Best New Restaurant" by Milwaukee Magazine's Reader's Choice, truly embodies the essence of farm-to-table cuisine. With a commitment to locally sourced and seasonal ingredients, each dish celebrates the authenticity and simplicity of modern American cooking. Patrons rave about the quality and freshness, with one guest exclaiming, "The food was beyond what we expected!" The restaurant's vibrant atmosphere and attentive service enhance the dining experience, making it a must-visit for those seeking a genuine farm-to-table meal. Eldr + Rime's dedication to excellence is evident in every meticulously crafted dish, from the flambéd cheese appetizer to the exquisite halibut, making each visit a delightful culinary journey.

A photo of Mitchell's Fish Market - Brookfield restaurant

7. Mitchell's Fish Market - Brookfield

3.9

Excellent(2411)

Price: Moderate

• American • Brookfield

Booked 18 times today

Mitchell's Fish Market in Brookfield stands out not just for its exceptional seafood but also for its sublime Steak offerings. Diners consistently rave about the succulent steaks, noting their perfect preparation and mouthwatering flavors. One glowing review mentioned, "The filet and stuffed salmon were outstanding," highlighting the quality and skill behind each dish. This Brookfield gem ensures each steak is cooked to perfection, offering a memorable dining experience that leaves guests planning their next visit. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply in the mood for a top-notch steak, Mitchell's Fish Market promises excellence on every plate.

A photo of Maggiano's - Milwaukee restaurant

8. Maggiano's - Milwaukee

4.6

Exceptional(2848)

Price: Moderate

• American • Milwaukee

Booked 65 times today

Maggiano's in Milwaukee's Mayfair Mall stands out as a beacon of American cuisine, offering an authentic taste of Italian-American heritage through Nonna’s cherished recipes. Nestled in Wauwatosa, this two-story culinary haven, complete with banquet rooms and a picturesque patio, provides not just a meal but a memorable dining experience. Reviews consistently praise its atmosphere and service, with one guest exclaiming, “Great food that meets up to its billing. Maggiano is in its own league!” Whether it’s the perfectly cooked asparagus, delectable lasagna, or the friendly, professional staff, Maggiano’s commitment to quality shines, making every visit a delightful celebration of American culinary excellence.

9. Red Circle Inn

4.6

Exceptional(1395)

Price: Expensive

• American • Nashotah

Booked 18 times today

Nestled in the historic heart of Nashotah, Wisconsin, Red Circle Inn has been a beacon of exceptional Comfort Food since 1848. This venerable establishment, lauded as Wisconsin's oldest restaurant, offers a culinary journey through time with its sublime dishes that evoke a sense of nostalgia and warmth. Patrons rave about the "tender and flavorful" ribs and the "perfectly cooked" bone-in tenderloin, highlighting the impeccable quality and heartwarming appeal of their meals. The restaurant's legacy of warm hospitality is evident, with guests noting the "outstanding service" and the cozy ambiance that makes every dining experience memorable. The Red Circle Inn, with its rich history and masterfully crafted Comfort Food, continues to be a cherished destination for those seeking a meal that feels like home.

10. Waterlin

4.1

Excellent(41)

Price: Moderate

• American • Menomonee Falls

Serving traditional Wisconsin comfort food with a modern twist, Waterlin embraces the roots of a tight-knit community drawn together for great food, drink and company. We welcome visitors and locals alike who seek an authentic experience, genuine hospitality and creative Midwestern fare.Join us every Friday night from 5PM - 9PM for our coveted Wisconsin Fish Fry. Meal includes a beer battered cod with house remoulade, Southern slaw, cornbread and fries. Enjoy at the bar or sitting at a table with a cold beer or craft cocktail to start your weekend off right. Waterlin is located in Delta Hotels by Marriott Milwaukee Northwest.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

D
Debbie
Wisconsin •73 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
Such a fun family night thank you. We enjoyed the new menu from start to finish. The menu paying homage to other restaurants is a delight and the WI touches duly noted (Schlitz on tap!) There are whispers of supper club but this is way too elevated for that. Service was charming and helpful. The backdrop of Jay’s decor, again so evocative of WI and the WI art is so appreciated. It all frames the food and the experience so well.
More info
The Commodore - A Bartolotta RestaurantPrice: Expensive• American• Hartland
•
4.5
R
Rosanna
Wisconsin •1 review
5.0
Dined 4 days ago
The dinner we had was fantastic, although our meals arrived just after the appetizers and we still didn’t get our wine yet. The server and manager quickly compensated us for this inconvenience and were very apologetic. Things happen, so pleased they accepted the issue and addressed it! Amazing service will definitely be back!
More info
Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant - Brookfield, WIPrice: Moderate• American• Brookfield
•
4.7
B
BrianVIP
Wisconsin •107 reviews
5.0
Dined 5 days ago
Fantastic place, as always. Can't beat the cinnamon roll during brunch - WOW.
More info
Eldr + RimePrice: Expensive• American• Wauwatosa
•
4.5
G
Gregory
Wisconsin •6 reviews
5.0
Dined on Dec 20, 2024
The setting was casual and elegant simultaneously - laid back white table cloth. Our server was knowledgeable and observant without hovering - well done. Our cocktails were delicious, well made. Side spinach and feta salads were of an appropriate size and made from fresh ingredients. Our entrees - scallops over risotto and pan fried whitefish - were fantastic. Well done - thumbs up!
More info
North Star American Bistro-BrookfieldPrice: Moderate• American• Brookfield
•
4.7
J
Jessica
Wisconsin •1 review
5.0
Dined on Dec 14, 2024
Excellent food and service! The French onion soup was amazing. The filet was one of the best steaks I've ever had.
More info
Butler InnPrice: Moderate• American• Pewaukee
•
4.2

Explore OpenTable

Sussex

American

Best American Restaurants in Sussex

Price

Regions

Neighbourhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

14 restaurants available nearby

1. North Star American Bistro-Brookfield

2. Butler Inn

3. Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant - Brookfield, WI

4. The Commodore - A Bartolotta Restaurant

5. Dave & Buster's - Wauwatosa

6. Eldr + Rime

7. Mitchell's Fish Market - Brookfield

8. Maggiano's - Milwaukee

9. Red Circle Inn

10. Waterlin

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable