Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York State

Best American Restaurants in West Islip

Price
Regions
Neighbourhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility

39 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Besito Mexican - West Islip restaurant
1. Besito Mexican - West Islip
4.7
Exceptional(1853)
Price: Moderate
• American • West Islip
Booked 16 times today
Besito Mexican in West Islip offers an exceptional dining experience with its authentic and upscale Contemporary Mexican cuisine. Known for its "absolutely delicious food every single time," Besito delights patrons with a diverse menu that includes standout dishes like the Shrimp Empanadas and Arrachera. Guests rave about the "best guacamole" and the "top-notch drinks," especially the margaritas, which perfectly complement the vibrant and welcoming atmosphere. The attentive and friendly service ensures that diners feel valued and comfortable, making it an ideal spot for any occasion. Come experience why Besito is a favorite for Mexican food enthusiasts on Long Island!
A photo of The James restaurant
2. The James
4.6
Exceptional(417)
Price: Very Expensive
• American • Babylon
Booked 46 times today
The James in Babylon is a stellar example of high-quality American cuisine. With an ambiance that "pays homage to the Carriage House," this elegant restaurant impresses with its attention to detail and impeccable service. Diners rave about the USDA Prime-grade steaks, fresh pastas, and locally sourced seafood, describing the food as "absolutely delicious" and "prepared to perfection." The atmosphere is vibrant yet welcoming, making it ideal for special occasions or a delightful night out. The James is more than just a meal; it's an experience that leaves guests eagerly planning their next visit, with many saying, "We will definitely be returning!"
A photo of Argyle Grill & Tavern restaurant
3. Argyle Grill & Tavern
4.6
Exceptional(35)
Price: Very Expensive
• American • Babylon
Booked 3 times today
Executive Chef: Chris WeissLocated in the heart of Babylon Village
A photo of Mito - Babylon restaurant
4. Mito - Babylon
3.5
Very Good(95)
Price: Expensive
• American • Babylon
Booked 5 times today
Mito - Babylon offers an authentic Asian culinary experience that captivates diners with its exquisite flavors and vibrant atmosphere. Known for its premium all-you-can-eat buffet, Mito features "unlimited Wagyu steak, premium seafood, and freshly crafted sushi" that are a true delight for the senses. Diners rave about the "amazing quality seafood and taste," with standout dishes like the dim sum sampler, pork soup dumplings, and the surf and turf roll. The ambiance, reminiscent of a New York City upscale venue, paired with exceptional service, makes Mito a "hidden gem" in Babylon. Whether it's a casual meal or a special celebration, Mito promises a memorable dining adventure.
A photo of Lily's Babylon restaurant
5. Lily's Babylon
4.5
Awesome(21)
Price: Expensive
• American • Babylon
Booked 6 times today
Our menu boasts Traditional American paired with Irish Pub Fare. From bar snacks to entrees, and traditional Irish fare to sandwiches, we’ve got what your palette’s craving!
A photo of The Lakehouse restaurant
6. The Lakehouse
4.7
Exceptional(3200)
Price: Expensive
• American • Bay Shore
Booked 22 times today
The Lakehouse in Bay Shore, NY, offers an exceptional French American dining experience, blending the sophistication of French culinary techniques with the comforting flavors of American cuisine. Guests rave about the “outstanding” dishes like grilled oysters, halibut, and Berkshire pork chops, which showcase the chef's finesse and creativity. The ambiance is equally praised, with a beautiful waterside setting that includes stunning views of the Great South Bay. The restaurant’s commitment to quality and hospitality is reflected in the “impeccable” service and meticulously plated dishes. Whether for a special occasion or a casual night out, The Lakehouse promises a memorable culinary journey.
A photo of Salt and Barrel restaurant
7. Salt and Barrel
4.8
Exceptional(1697)
Price: Expensive
• American • Bay Shore
Booked 18 times today
An authentic oyster bar with an urban vibe and vintage soul. Serving classic cocktails, craft taps, and coastal fare with a rotating selection of east/west coast oysters daily.
A photo of ITA Kitchen restaurant
8. ITA Kitchen
4.4
Awesome(970)
Price: Expensive
• American • Bay Shore
Booked 17 times today
ITA Kitchen in Bay Shore redefines what it means to enjoy authentic American cuisine, presented with a delightful Italian twist. Diners rave about the "outstanding food and wonderful service," making it a standout destination for those seeking a memorable dining experience. Reviews highlight the restaurant's innovative take on traditional dishes, such as the "phenomenal table-side mozzarella" and "amazing chicken picante," reflecting a creative fusion that respects classic American flavors. The vibrant atmosphere, coupled with enthusiastic and attentive staff, ensures that every visit is not just a meal but a celebration, making ITA Kitchen a must-visit for American cuisine enthusiasts.
A photo of Roadtrip restaurant
9. Roadtrip
4.5
Awesome(97)
Price: Expensive
• American • Bay Shore
Booked 7 times today
Roadtrip in Bay Shore is a true haven for barbecue enthusiasts, offering an unforgettable dining experience that promises "melt in your mouth juicy and delicious" brisket and perfectly cooked ribs. The on-site smoked BBQ is a standout, drawing diners back for its authentic and flavorful taste. Guests rave about the large portions and exceptional quality, making it a must-try for anyone seeking genuine American BBQ. The restaurant's unique approach of highlighting different states each week adds a creative twist, ensuring a fresh and exciting menu every visit. With great service and a welcoming atmosphere, Roadtrip is a culinary gem in Bay Shore.
A photo of The Linwood Restaurant and Cocktails restaurant
10. The Linwood Restaurant and Cocktails
4.8
Exceptional(827)
Price: Moderate
• American • Bay Shore
Booked 10 times today
The Linwood Restaurant and Cocktails in Bay Shore is a standout in the realm of Gastro Pub cuisine, offering "consistently delicious food" that perfectly complements its thoughtfully crafted cocktails and vibrant atmosphere. This American Gastropub creates an inviting ambiance with its "beautifully presented" dishes, such as the grilled octopus and signature meatloaf, which have earned high praise from diners. The Linwood excels in providing an exceptional dining experience, described by patrons as "a South Shore gem" with superb menu selections that never fail to impress. The "friendly, professional" staff add to the charm, making every visit memorable and worth repeating.
‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
  • LindaVIP
    New York City •8 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 3 days ago
    Wonderful evening at the Argyle! Busy Saturday crowd made for a crowded bar but it’s a lively and fun crowd and the bartender made sure we didn’t wait long form drink! After our pre dinner cocktail we were sat in the beautiful dining room for really superior dinner! Every dish was delicious! Can highly recommend!
    More info
    Argyle Grill & TavernPrice: Very Expensive• American• Babylon
    •
    4.6
  • SandyVIP
    San Francisco Bay Area •5 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 4 days ago
    This was our fourth experience having dinner here, at The Janes, and honestly, it was just as wonderful as the time before! The food and service are absolutely amazing! It is remarkable how friendly every single staff member is, and the food is perfect every time. My husband had the NY Strip with blueberry butter, and loved it, as did our friends who had joined us. They also had to try the flaming sticky toffee and the chocolate layer cake, which was delicious as well. Always a fantastic experience.
    More info
    The JamesPrice: Very Expensive• Continental• Babylon
    •
    4.6
  • Donald
    New York State •1 review
    5.0
    Dined 5 days ago
    The staff is very attentive and work very well together. The food is soooo good. We have eaten here many times and have not been disappointed.
    More info
    Besito Mexican - West IslipPrice: Moderate• Mexican• West Islip
    •
    4.7
  • Madeline
    New York City •9 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 7 days ago
    This was the first time dining at the Lakehouse and we will definitely be back. We had lunch to celebrate my mom’s birthday and upon walking in, the place is beautiful and so cozy. We started with calamari as an appetizer which was delicious- the lemon honey aioli was a nice touch. We then had the farm green salad which also was tasty and ended our meal with a Lakehouse burger. Highly recommend and looking forward to going back again.
    More info
    The LakehousePrice: Expensive• Contemporary American• Bay Shore
    •
    4.7
  • Michael
    New York State •1 review
    5.0
    Dined on Feb 14, 2025
    Love this place, the food is always good and the drinks are as well
    More info
    Mito - BabylonPrice: Expensive• Japanese• Babylon
    •
    3.5

Explore OpenTable

Discover
OpenTable
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Press
More
Our sites
Businesses
  • Delight more diners
  • Open for Business Blog
Join us on
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2024 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 500, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo