Best Burgers Restaurants in Cresskill

Hamburgers were amazing! Service was outstanding! A little loud but lively is good! Had a great meal and with a reservation - we were in and out in 45 minutes during one of the busiest weekends of the year in the city. Highly recommend!

This place is one of our “go to” places to eat whenever we visit NYC. This particular location is located across from Carnegie Hall and is just a couple of blocks away from Central Park where the horse carriage ride tours meet. Although they have so many delicious menu items, they have what I consider one of the most perfect pastrami Reubens made with their in house made pastrami. It’s super moist and tender and delicious. One day I’m going to have to try their chicken pot pie. I see that it’s a favorite by many of the customers and the puff pastry looks so fluffy and flaky. Richie was our server and he was attentive, patient, helpful, and very friendly. He was a great conversationalist when we asked him about NYC and his personal experiences in general. We love this place. Cozy, great food, great location, and it will always be one of our favorite places to eat whenever we visit NYC.

Great food and service. Lovely atmosphere. For that price, you'd think fries would come with the burger. There's better burgers in the neighborhood but if you want a nice sit-down atmosphere, this is great. Just be prepared to spend some bucks.

Great meal. Maitre ‘d was excellent. Moved people around to get us seated when our table was not available. Very helpful and resourceful.

Great pastrami sandwiches true to the Carnegie tradition and reputation for the best sandwiches for generations. Celebrated my birthday with a huge slice of German chocolate cake enough for six adults! Wonderful staff and Great experience!