Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York State

Best Italian Restaurants in Bay Shore

Price
Regions
Neighbourhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility

17 restaurants available nearby

A photo of ITA Kitchen restaurant
4.3
Awesome(939)
Price: Expensive
• Italian • Bay Shore
Booked 22 times today
Experience the true essence of American cuisine at ITA Kitchen in the heart of Bay Shore's quaint village. Renowned for its innovative approach to Italian-American dishes, ITA Kitchen consistently impresses with its "outstanding" food and "wonderful" service, as noted by numerous glowing reviews. Guests rave about the authenticity and quality, highlighting dishes like the "phenomenal" meatballs and the "divine" Rainbow Cookie Martini. The vibrant atmosphere, coupled with the friendly and attentive staff, ensures every meal is memorable. As one diner put it, ITA Kitchen is "by far the best Italian restaurant on Long Island!!!!" making it a must-visit for anyone seeking a top-notch dining experience.
A photo of Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore restaurant
4.6
Exceptional(964)
Price: Moderate
• Italian • Bay Shore
Booked 9 times today
Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore is a beacon of American cuisine in Bay Shore, renowned for its commitment to quality and authenticity. This spot dazzles diners with its rustic yet modern American offerings, creatively prepared with locally sourced ingredients. Patrons rave about their culinary experience, highlighting dishes like the "out of this world" pork chop and the "always delicious" double cut pork chop, which have become fan favorites. The atmosphere is equally praised, with live music and an industrial chic decor that adds an extra layer of delight. Reviewers consistently mention the "excellent service" and the warm welcome from staff, making Butera's a must-visit for a truly memorable American dining experience.
A photo of Bella Vie restaurant
4.7
Exceptional(552)
Price: Moderate
• Italian • Bay Shore
Booked 2 times today
Bella Vie, nestled in the picturesque waterfront of Bay Shore, is a beacon of French culinary excellence. This award-winning establishment is celebrated for its authentic French cuisine, where each dish promises a symphony of flavors. Patrons rave about the "outstanding" food and service, with reviews highlighting dishes like the French onion soup as "delicious." The atmosphere is equally praised, providing a romantic setting that enhances the dining experience. The glowing testimonial, "the red sauce absolutely the BEST!!!" encapsulates the high-quality and authenticity that Bella Vie consistently delivers. It's no wonder diners are eager to return, making it a prized gem in Bay Shore for French cuisine aficionados.
A photo of Primi Italian Steakhouse restaurant
4.8
Exceptional(1418)
Price: Very Expensive
• Italian • West Islip
Booked 28 times today
Primi Italian Steakhouse in West Islip is a beacon of culinary excellence, celebrated for its fusion of authentic Italian cuisine and superb dry-aged prime steaks. Diners consistently rave about the "wonderful" porterhouse and the "best steak on Long Island," highlighting the quality and preparation of their meats. One guest excitedly shared, "My Porterhouse for 2 was cooked perfectly, tender and delicious." With a speakeasy vibe and options to dine by a cozy fireplace or enjoy live jazz, Primi promises not just a meal but an "incredible experience" as echoed by many guests. Whether it's the "delicious" filet mignon or the festive atmosphere, Primi Italian Steakhouse stands out as a premier destination for steak lovers.
A photo of Marys Pizza & Restaurant restaurant
4.9
Exceptional(48)
Price: Moderate
• Italian • East Islip
Booked 2 times today
At Marys Pizza & Restaurant, nestled in the heart of East Islip and Islip Terrace, diners indulge in a symphony of authentic Italian flavors that resonate with every bite. Celebrated for its "best pizza around" and acclaimed "best vodka sauce in the game," Marys offers a culinary journey that transcends the ordinary. Guests rave about the "unbelievably excellent" chicken hero and the lasagna that makes you say "OMG!" The commitment to authenticity and quality is palpable, as one diner highlighted, "Whether it's pizza or pasta dishes; whatever your tummy desires, it's fresh, well prepared and delicious!" With its charming atmosphere and consistently lauded service, Marys Pizza & Restaurant is a beacon of Italian culinary excellence in Suffolk County.
A photo of One10 Modern Italian restaurant
4.5
Awesome(2716)
Price: Very Expensive
• Italian • Melville
Booked 45 times today
One10 Modern Italian in Melville stands out as a beacon of Mediterranean excellence, delighting guests with its authentic and luxurious culinary offerings. The restaurant's dedication to quality shines through in its menu, which features the finest locally sourced ingredients, from hand-made pastas to the freshest seafood. Diners consistently praise the "bold flavors" and innovative takes on classic Mediterranean dishes. The ambiance, described as "modern yet inviting," complements the dining experience, making every visit memorable. Glowing testimonials highlight the "incredible food" and "exceptional service," with special mentions of dishes like the Chilean Sea Bass and Pasta Bolognese. One10 Modern Italian isn’t just a meal; it’s a Mediterranean journey right in the heart of Long Island.
A photo of Smithtown Pasta House restaurant
4.5
Awesome(333)
Price: Moderate
• Italian • Smithtown
Booked 3 times today
Discover the heart of American dining at Smithtown Pasta House, a beloved gem in Smithtown renowned for its exceptional cuisine and inviting atmosphere. Celebrated for transforming classic American dishes with a unique twist, this restaurant ensures every meal is both comforting and delightfully surprising. Guests rave about the "always delicious" menu, highlighting favorites like the shrimp risotto and linguine carbonara, which are prepared to perfection. The ambiance is described as "cozy" and "welcoming," making diners feel right at home. Praised for its "phenomenal food, service, and atmosphere," Smithtown Pasta House is the go-to spot for those seeking a truly American dining experience. Whether it's a family gathering or a quiet dinner, every visit is a reason to celebrate.
A photo of Osteria Umbra restaurant
4.9
Exceptional(1832)
Price: Expensive
• Italian • Smithtown
Booked 30 times today
Italian hospitality and culinary traditions come together at Osteria UmbraExecutive Chef Marco Pellegrini & his wife, Chef de Cuisine, Sabrina Vallorini transport you to their hometown of Foligno, Umbria where quality craftsmanship and a deep respect for natural ingredients are woven into daily culture.At Osteria Umbra, Chef Marco Pellegrini has created an experience inspired by classic Umbrian cuisine, elevated by his attention to detail and culinary innovation.Each dish is handmade with the world’s finest ingredients; from the farms right here in our backyard to the rolling hills of Italy.This vision would not be possible without Stephen and Diane Bragoli & Daniel Bragoli, lover of all things food and wine.It is their attention to detail that creates a comfortable ambiance that represents the contemporary Italy of today combined with Chef Marco’s soulful cuisine that Osteria Umbra is born.
A photo of Trento Italian Steak House restaurant
4.8
Exceptional(1672)
Price: Very Expensive
• Italian • Farmingdale
Booked 23 times today
Trento Italian Steak House in Farmingdale is a gem for those seeking an authentic and high-quality Steakhouse experience. Specializing in prime aged steaks, this upscale restaurant, managed by the Branchinelli family, consistently delights diners with its "outstanding" culinary offerings. Guests rave about the "delicious food & drinks" and commend the exceptional service, noting that the staff, like Ray and Kumar, provide recommendations that never disappoint. One patron exclaimed about the steak special, "Cajun rubbed with Wagyu butter. Omgee," highlighting the unique and flavorful twists Trento adds to its dishes. Whether it's a special occasion or a casual outing, Trento Italian Steak House promises a memorable dining experience, making every visit "perfect."
A photo of Steve's Piccola Bussola of Hauppauge restaurant
4.7
Exceptional(508)
Price: Expensive
• Italian • Hauppauge
Booked 8 times today
At Steve's Piccola Bussola of Hauppauge, the fish dishes are a true standout, reflecting the restaurant's commitment to freshness and quality. Nestled in the heart of Hauppauge, this establishment is renowned for serving delectable fish cuisine that consistently earns rave reviews. Patrons particularly praise the "outstanding branzino" and the diverse menu that allows customization of dishes with preferred sauces, enhancing the dining experience. The restaurant's ability to combine traditional Italian flavors with high-quality seafood is unmatched. As one reviewer excitedly shares, "Get the stuffed artichokes and chicken scarpariello - you will thank me later!!!" Steve's Piccola Bussola is your go-to destination for an authentic and memorable fish dining experience, where every dish served is a testament to the culinary prowess and passion of its team.

How is content generated

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
  • Lisavip
    New York State •89 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 2 days ago
    Last minute date night. I am in the hospitality business, work down Main Street in Islip. My happy, delicious go to place is Butera’s in Bay Shore. Food spot on (always) front desk, bartendar Chris thank you for my pumpkin martini ….. looking forward to the new winter cocktails starting this weekend! Tara was our server, we love her. See you soon Butera’s AND we 🩷 Christine!
    More info
    Butera's Restaurant of Bay ShorePrice: Moderate• Italian• Bay Shore
    4.6
  • Kristen
    New York City •3 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 5 days ago
    All was great w the exception of the server squeezing a to go bag on the table full of wine glasses leading to me having a full glass of red wine in my lap! Luckily it was the end of the dinner so I at least enjoyed my night for the most part!
    More info
    Primi Italian SteakhousePrice: Very Expensive• Italian• West Islip
    4.8
  • Patriciavip
    New York City •35 reviews
    4.0
    Dined 6 days ago
    Lovely little bistro. Excellent food and service makes this a win win local spot. Plus the view of the lake is enchanting.
    More info
    Bella ViePrice: Moderate• Italian• Bay Shore
    4.7
  • Kimvip
    New York City •36 reviews
    5.0
    Dined on Nov 23, 2024
    Absolutely everything we ordered was perfect. And it was hard to make a decision so we’ll have to to come back. There were so many options that I loved. My friend and I ordered dirty martinis, mine had blue cheese, stuffed olives, and hers did not because she doesn’t like that. They were perfect. Then we both ordered a Manhattan with Rye, which was also lovely, although the restaurant should probably invest in some better cherries… You should have Amarena cherries on hand with craft cocktails.  For appetizers, we got the risotto balls, the meatballs, and the artichokes oreganata… Everything was fantastic and we took some home. For dinner I ordered the Andrew’s chicken, my husband ordered the spicy chicken with the cherry peppers, and our friends ordered the shrimp over spinach. We were way too full for dessert but next time I’m getting the espresso martini flight for dessert! Our waiter was not around enough, but he was super busy from what I could tell— the place was jammin.’ However, there is plenty of other busing staff and food runners that were always on hand to help with anything we needed. We will definitely be back. 
    More info
    ITA KitchenPrice: Expensive• Italian• Bay Shore
    4.3
  • Kristin
    New York City •1 review
    5.0
    Dined on Nov 18, 2024
    Marys is my favorite resturant. I had my wedding there. It’s Our place for every occasions and the occasional week night dinner.
    More info
    Marys Pizza & RestaurantPrice: Moderate• Italian• East Islip
    4.9

Discover best Italian restaurants in Bay Shore

Discover the essence of Italian cuisine in Bay Shore, Suffolk, where a variety of restaurants offer an authentic taste of Italy right in the heart of New York State. Each establishment boasts unique interpretations of classic Italian dishes, blending traditional flavors with local ingredients to create mouth-watering menus that cater to all palates. From rustic, cozy atmospheres to modern, elegant settings, the dining scene in Bay Shore provides an ideal backdrop for both casual and sophisticated dining experiences. Patrons can expect top-notch service, high-quality food, and an ambiance that complements the rich, culinary heritage of Italy. Whether you're in the mood for hearty pasta, exquisite seafood, or a fine wine selection, Bay Shore's Italian restaurants promise a memorable dining experience. Embrace the local love for Italian cuisine in this vibrant community, where every meal is served with a touch of Italian hospitality.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2024 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 500, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo