Best Italian Restaurants in Hawthorne

We will def be going back. A little pricey but def a bit above in terms of quality of food. A great place to celebrate our daughter’s birthday!

The food was amazing. The antipasto board that was presented was phenomenal. Our server was excellent, and the music by Josh was awesome. It was a very pleasant night for some guests experiencing it for the first time. Everyone had a wonderful evening.

We had an exceptional experience at Felina tonight! Our last-minute decision to dine there turned out to be the perfect choice. My dad, who was visiting, came along and immediately noticed the outstanding service—the manager was truly dedicated, checking in with every table to ensure guests were enjoying their meals and feeling taken care of. He personally stopped by our table multiple times, which added a special touch to the evening. The ambiance is both chic and welcoming, striking the perfect balance between trendy and comfortable. The service was prompt and friendly, making us feel right at home. As always, the food was absolutely delicious—each dish was crafted with care, and the flavors were top-notch. We also thoroughly enjoyed the live music, which added a wonderful vibe to the night. Living in Ridgewood, we’re lucky to have such a gem in town. Felina has consistently been one of our go-to spots because it’s a place that never disappoints, whether we’re craving great food, impeccable service, or just a night out in a lively atmosphere. Highly recommend it for anyone looking for a memorable dining experience!

Biagio’s has become our go-to spot for romantic dinners, and for good reason. My wife and I had our wedding reception at The Terrace last year, and every time we dine here, it takes us right back to that unforgettable night. The food, the atmosphere—everything is just as amazing as we remember. 10/10, highly recommend!

Went for Valentine’s Day and was pleasantly surprised that there was a special menu but also regular menu was also available. We chose the special menu which was very reasonably priced at $90 for two with options for each course. Started with burrata caprese. Nice size portion and cheese very good but tomatoes were not that flavorful. (Other option was fried zucchini) Next was Caesar salad- tasty and not overdressed (other option was garden salad) Next was main dish. I had Branzino with mashed potatoes and vegetables. Delicious and enough for 2 meals. Husband had scallops with risotto which he enjoyed. There were 4 choices for entrees. Dessert was a medley of sweets. The churro was the best of the group. Coffee was included. Atmosphere was nice. Servers very pleasant. We had an 8 pm reservation and were seated immediately and were not rushed. Nice amount of time between courses Overall an excellent meal.