Best Italian Restaurants in Long Key

The food was delicious!!! My husband got fettuccine with chicken and I got ravioli in a crab and shrimp sauce. Both were amazing!! Service was top notch. Fair pricing for tourist area with wonderful service.

As always, this is a great restaurant for brunch. It's not fancy, but has more of a tropical feel. Innovative menu choices. Had the Rosti, which was great as always. Did not have a surcharge for the increased price of eggs. One of our favorites in Key West!

Wonderful experience with our two good friends who had always intended to go to Antonia's but never got around to doing it. It was as marvelous as always, and we had the great server, Duane (or Dwayne?) we've had before. The food and bar items were top-notch. Excellent experience all around.

Great service and food is fabulous. Loved it so much we went twice while on vacation. Damian and tall Christopher were our waiters and did an excellent job.

We had four appetizers and dessert. We both liked the outstanding ceviche, and the very good burrata preparations. The octopus was ok, not great, and Jane liked the mushroom soup with taleggio more than I did. She loved the taleggio in the soup and I thought it hurt more than helped the flavor, so if you love taleggio, a very smelly cheese, you will probably like the soup. The key lime pie was also excellent. The service was slow to start, no one getting to the table after we were seated for about ten or more minutes, but after that it was pleasant and prompt. It has nice views of the marina but to get a window table, of which there are about a dozen, you have to reserve early. There are four or five outdoor tables on the deck. It is a little out of the way of the nearby marina area conch republic type places, being upstairs, and Italian fine dining rather than Key West dining, so we thought it would much less crowded, but it filled up pretty well for a Thursday evening. Prices of the apps were $15-$22, not too bad, and the KL pie was $12. The mains are mostly in the $40s and $50. We had an excellent Abruzzi Pecorino white wine for $36. We will go back.