Best Italian Restaurants in New Albany

Ambiance is so romantic and cozy, elegant and fun. Scarpinocc was so bright and flavorful, and Veal Parm outstanding as well. Hayley was excellent, we will be back!

I’ve been many times at Brio and I really like food and service. I only like to sit at the back though because the main room is too noisy for me and also it has a weird smell that’s been there for many years.

The expanded bar is a real gem at Giammarco's. They now have a music stage and much more seating since they pretty much doubled in size. They also have a somewhat private seating area within the bar if you want a little quieter experience. And a second bar now allows more bar seating for those who prefer that to being at a table. There are high-tops and low-tops in the bar, all with a view of the music stage. Check it out!

My family and I had an amazing dining experience at Marcella’s Italian Kitchen in Polaris! From the moment we walked in, the staff was warm and welcoming. The atmosphere was cozy yet lively, perfect for a family dinner. The food was absolutely delicious—every dish was cooked to perfection, from the fresh pasta to the flavorful sauces. The standout for us was the spaghetti meatballs and Tiramisu which was phenomenal. The service was impeccable, with our server making great recommendations and ensuring we had everything we needed. We will definitely be returning and highly recommend this spot to anyone looking for a memorable Italian meal!

If you’re looking for amazing unique food and unique atmosphere…this is the place for you! You will also get visited by the owner at some point in the meal. Love this place.