Best Italian Restaurants in St. Augustine

The food was really good! We had a filet and fettuccine with shrimp. We also had calamari and lamb lollipops. The bread needs improvement. The only negative part of the meal was the service. It took us over 25 minutes for our server to allow us to order appetizers. Other than that, we sat in the main dining room and it was beautiful and the food was delicious!

A Delightful Dining Experience From the moment I walked in, I knew I was in for a treat. The warm and inviting ambiance, paired with a friendly greeting from the host, set the tone for an exceptional dining experience. I started with an appetizer that was beautifully plated and packed with flavor. The main course was cooked to perfection—tender, flavorful, and perfectly seasoned. The portion sizes were generous, and the presentation was top-notch. The service was impeccable. Our server was attentive without being intrusive, offering excellent recommendations and ensuring we had everything we needed. Despite the restaurant being busy, our food arrived promptly, and we never felt rushed. To top it off, dessert was an absolute showstopper. It was a perfect balance of sweet and rich, leaving me wishing I had room for more. Overall, this restaurant delivered an outstanding experience, from the food to the service and ambiance. Whether you’re looking for a casual night out or a special occasion spot, this place is a must-visit. I can’t wait to return! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Excellent food and service. Portion size was more than enough. I also loved the wine selection and appreciated the warm bread.

Dinner was amazing as usual. Several of us had the eggplant rollatini which is always one of my favorites, some had the agnolotti and another the radiatori along with caesar salads and we all raved about our selections. They use quality ingredients and fresh seasonings as they do at all Medura brother’s restaurants. We were celebrating 3 birthdays that evening and what made the evening even better was the exceptional service. Melanie was our server and she was outstanding! Very personable, efficient and very committed to making sure we had the best dining experience ever. She made sure all our wines were to our liking and dinners were prepared, along with our splitting some entrees, were perfection. She was also so kind and thoughtful to treat us to a few shareable Midtown Table ice cream, which I must say was unbelievably delicious! We all agreed, based on the description. we would not have ordered it but so glad to have tried it! We will definitely have that again Then to top it off-Melanie managed to accommodate our separate checks with shared items to perfection. Definitely mathematically inclined as well! Fabulous night all around! Thanks Midtown Table!

The Penne with the tomato cream sauce is excellent.