Best Southwest American Restaurants in Westerville

50 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Eddie Merlot's Prime Aged Beef & Seafood - Columbus restaurant

1. Eddie Merlot's Prime Aged Beef & Seafood - Columbus

4.8

Exceptional(5622)

Price: Very Expensive

• Mexican • Polaris

Booked 38 times today

At Eddie Merlot’s in Polaris, Columbus, seafood lovers can indulge in a dining experience that marries quality with culinary artistry. Known for its "Seafood Tower," Eddie Merlot’s offers generous portions of freshly sourced tuna, oysters, crab legs, and shrimp, each accompanied by an array of perfectly paired sauces. Patrons consistently praise the seafood's freshness and the meticulous preparation that enhances its natural flavors. As one satisfied customer stated, the seafood is "pricey because of generous portions... but worth every bite of it." This establishment not only promises an exceptional seafood experience but delivers it with every dish, making it a must-visit for those seeking authentic and high-quality seafood in Columbus.

A photo of Napa Kitchen + Bar - Westerville restaurant

2. Napa Kitchen + Bar - Westerville

4.6

Exceptional(785)

Price: Moderate

• Mexican • Westerville

Booked 14 times today

Napa Kitchen + Bar in Westerville is a haven for American cuisine enthusiasts seeking an authentic dining experience. Patrons rave about the "melt in your mouth" veal meatball starter and the "delicious" shrimp and risotto, highlighting the culinary prowess that Napa Kitchen consistently delivers. It's not just the food that makes this place stand out; the "fantastic" wine selection complements each dish perfectly, creating a truly harmonious dining experience. Guests consistently praise the "exceptional" service and the warm, inviting ambiance, making it a "hidden gem" worth checking out. Whether it's for a casual brunch or a special anniversary dinner, Napa Kitchen + Bar delivers an American dining experience that exceeds expectations, with many promising to become regulars.

3. Polaris Grill

4.8

Exceptional(5118)

Price: Moderate

• Mexican • Polaris

Booked 38 times today

Polaris Grill in Columbus remains a beacon of exquisite Contemporary American cuisine, celebrated for its unique culinary creations like the "55" salad, and Wild mushroom bisque. The restaurant thrives under the ownership of Darren Greene, ensuring a delightful dining experience highlighted by fresh seafood and succulent steaks. Patrons consistently praise the attentive, knowledgeable service and the inviting ambiance, making it a preferred destination for both casual and special occasions. Reviews often highlight dishes such as the BBQ Baby back ribs and the Aztec Chowder, raving that they are "the best I’ve tasted in Columbus." Polaris Grill is not just a meal; it's a memorable dining adventure, perfect for anyone wanting to experience the pinnacle of local cuisine.

A photo of Rusty Bucket - Westerville restaurant

4. Rusty Bucket - Westerville

4.6

Exceptional(512)

Price: Moderate

• Mexican • Columbus

Booked 15 times today

Rusty Bucket in Westerville, Columbus, is a treasure trove of American cuisine, offering a vibrant slice of Americana in every dish. Praised for its "highest quality food and beverage", this neighborhood tavern is the epitome of comfort and quality. Patrons rave about the classics, from the "very good" Beef Stroganoff and French onion soup to the beloved meatloaf dinner. A standout is the friendly, efficient service, with shout-outs to staff like Sam and Bettina who make dining here a delight. Whether it's the bustling atmosphere or the "always good" diverse menu, Rusty Bucket is a go-to spot for authentic American dining in a welcoming, "come as you are" setting.

5. Giammarco's

4.6

Exceptional(1948)

Price: Moderate

• Mexican • Westerville

Booked 27 times today

At Giammarco’s in Westerville, you're guaranteed an authentic slice of Italy with every dish served. Renowned for having the best spaghetti and lasagna as voted by the Columbus Dispatch, this esteemed restaurant prides itself on using fresh, top-quality ingredients and cherished family recipes to craft their mouth-watering Italian cuisine. Patrons consistently rave about the "fabulous food" and "wonderful ambiance," with special mentions to the "best lasagna I’ve ever eaten!" Whether you're enjoying a lively dinner on their music-filled patio or savoring hand-rolled pizzas and individually sautéed entrees, Giammarco’s promises a truly Italian dining experience that will make you return time and again. Bon appetito at Giammarco’s!

A photo of Flour Modern Pasta Bar restaurant

6. Flour Modern Pasta Bar

4.4

Awesome(54)

Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Polaris

Booked 32 times today

Welcome to our modern pasta bar, where we blend global flavors and pasta shapes with the comforting traditions of Midwest cuisine. All our pasta is freshly made in-house, ensuring quality and flavor in every dish. Located in the Polaris Mall next to Barnes and Nobles Enjoy an easy and affordable preset menu for dinner, featuring salads, in house baked breads, a variety of handmade pastas, and delightful desserts. Our focus on craft cocktails with local spirits promises to bring a fresh vibe to the Polaris Cocktail scene.Join us for a memorable dining experience that combines tradition with innovation in a vibrant atmosphere by Chef Yash Kishinchand and the family of Rooh Columbus.

A photo of Firebirds Wood Fired Grill - Columbus restaurant

7. Firebirds Wood Fired Grill - Columbus

4.5

Awesome(3526)

Price: Moderate

• Mexican • Polaris

Booked 77 times today

Firebirds Wood Fired Grill in Polaris, Columbus, is a haven for wine enthusiasts and food lovers alike, offering an exceptional Wine Bar experience. Known for its vibrant ambiance and top-notch service, the restaurant boasts a curated selection of wines that perfectly complement their wood-fired steaks and sumptuous sides. Guests frequently praise the knowledgeable staff and the specialty cocktails, with the Diamond Back Pineapple Martinis being a crowd favorite. The glowing reviews highlight the "outstanding food and fantastic service," making Firebirds a must-visit destination for anyone seeking a superior dining experience. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply indulging in a delectable meal, Firebirds Wood Fired Grill promises an unforgettable experience with every sip and bite.

8. Nomad

4.8

Exceptional(1026)

Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Polaris

Booked 20 times today

At Nomad in Polaris, Columbus, diners are treated to an extraordinary culinary journey that exemplifies the best of Global, International cuisine. This gem is celebrated for its innovative and wonderfully diverse menu, offering dishes that are as authentic as they are creative. The use of a Josper oven lends a unique flavor to dishes, with one reviewer exclaiming, "The Josper oven dishes are a must-try; they bring a delightful smoky touch that enhances the taste!" From the Moroccan Couscous to the Lomo Saltado, each dish is prepared with meticulous care, ensuring a palatable adventure for all tastes. The cocktails are just as impressive, with patrons praising mixologist Jeremy for his "master of delicious drinks." Nomad's commitment to a high-quality, eclectic dining experience makes it a standout destination for food lovers seeking the thrill of global flavors in Columbus.

9. The Two-One

4.3

Awesome(207)

Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Westerville

Booked 3 times today

Boldly confident food and drink, designed to be enjoyed in a relaxed, natural setting. The Two-One will inspire true comradery. Stop by and join us as we tempt your palate with fresh, locally sourced, farmer’s market inspired creations perfect for a special night out or a casual picnic-style meetup.

A photo of North High Brewing - Westerville restaurant

10. North High Brewing - Westerville

4.4

Awesome(107)

Price: Moderate

• Mexican • Westerville

Booked 21 times today

North High Brewing in Westerville is a treasure trove of authentic American cuisine, paired perfectly with award-winning craft beers. This beloved spot, nestled in the heart of the community, is renowned for its "EXCELLENT" from-scratch bites that keep patrons coming back. Guests rave about the "Fantastic burger ('the standard')" and the "very tasty and good portion sizes" of food. Its vibrant atmosphere is complemented by "friendly servers" and an inviting space suitable for any occasion—from family dinners to casual hangouts. Whether it’s enjoying a meal on the beautiful patio or cozying up in the dining room, North High Brewing promises a memorable experience with every visit, making it an essential destination for genuine American dining in Westerville.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

Westerville

Mexican

Best Southwest American Restaurants in Westerville

Price

Regions

Neighbourhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

50 restaurants available nearby

1. Eddie Merlot's Prime Aged Beef & Seafood - Columbus

2. Napa Kitchen + Bar - Westerville

3. Polaris Grill

4. Rusty Bucket - Westerville

5. Giammarco's

6. Flour Modern Pasta Bar

7. Firebirds Wood Fired Grill - Columbus

8. Nomad

9. The Two-One

10. North High Brewing - Westerville

Explore OpenTable