Best Seafood Restaurants in Peapack-Gladstone

Great food with great service, have been here multiple times and is always fantastic!

The service and views were great. Everyone was so kind and attentive. There were some great value wines on the menu and we really enjoyed what we had. Everything from the apps to dessert tasted great! Never felt rushed.

The specials were delicious (lobster bisque and scallops), but the guacamole and chips were a little boring and I prefer crispy brussel sprouts. It's a little too crowded in the dining room. My two-top was just too close to the other tables, so much so that I couldn't even take off/put on my jacket without hitting someone. The service was great, but it was hard for them to access our table.

One of our favorite spots. But our valentines night experience was not as perfect as it usually is. My wife's cosmo that she normally orders was not made to its usual standard. Our server had them make it over, but it still was not very good, so she had to completely change her drink order. We ordered one of our favorite apps, the meatballs, and that too was not up to its usual standard. However, the crab cakes were great, and our surf and turf was excellent. The lobster melted in our mouth n the steak was tender n juicy. Naomi, our server, was extremely gracious and attentive. She even had the manager come over n apologize for the drink problem we had. All in all, a good night.

Food, drinks and service were exceptional. One meal was not quite done to our liking but the Manager quickly rectified it and made sure that we were satisfied. Exactly what you would expect from a first class restaurant.