3 Best Sicilian Restaurants In Fire Island

3 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Butera's Restaurant of Sayville restaurant

1. Butera's Restaurant of Sayville

4.5

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Sayville

Booked 20 times today

Butera's Restaurant of Sayville is a cornerstone in the American dining scene, celebrated for its exceptional cuisine and the unique family-style dining experience it offers. Nestled in the heart of Sayville, this restaurant prides itself on serving up dishes that are both heartwarming and exquisite. Patrons rave about the "fabulous dining experience" and the "consistently good" quality of the food. Signature American dishes like chicken parm and burgers are given an Italian twist, making Butera's a culinary standout. The ambiance is described as "terrific" and the staff as "very friendly," creating an inviting atmosphere that complements the delicious meals. Whether it's for a casual lunch or a special occasion, Butera's promises a memorable dining experience with every visit.

A photo of Marys Pizza & Restaurant restaurant

2. Marys Pizza & Restaurant

4.7

Exceptional(48)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • East Islip

Booked 3 times today

At Marys Pizza & Restaurant, nestled in the heart of East Islip and Islip Terrace, diners indulge in a symphony of authentic Italian flavors that resonate with every bite. Celebrated for its "best pizza around" and acclaimed "best vodka sauce in the game," Marys offers a culinary journey that transcends the ordinary. Guests rave about the "unbelievably excellent" chicken hero and the lasagna that makes you say "OMG!" The commitment to authenticity and quality is palpable, as one diner highlighted, "Whether it's pizza or pasta dishes; whatever your tummy desires, it's fresh, well prepared and delicious!" With its charming atmosphere and consistently lauded service, Marys Pizza & Restaurant is a beacon of Italian culinary excellence in Suffolk County.

A photo of Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore restaurant

3. Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore

4.6

Exceptional(960)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Bay Shore

Booked 29 times today

Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore is a beacon of American cuisine in Bay Shore, renowned for its commitment to quality and authenticity. This spot dazzles diners with its rustic yet modern American offerings, creatively prepared with locally sourced ingredients. Patrons rave about their culinary experience, highlighting dishes like the "out of this world" pork chop and the "always delicious" double cut pork chop, which have become fan favorites. The atmosphere is equally praised, with live music and an industrial chic decor that adds an extra layer of delight. Reviewers consistently mention the "excellent service" and the warm welcome from staff, making Butera's a must-visit for a truly memorable American dining experience.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Best Sicilian Restaurants in Fire Island

Price

Regions

Neighbourhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

3 restaurants available nearby

1. Butera's Restaurant of Sayville

2. Marys Pizza & Restaurant

3. Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable