Best Sicilian Restaurants in Fishers Island

This place transports you to an authentic Italian trattoria. Food was excellent but the space is small.

While the host was a bit abrupt and assertive, it was easy to overlook given the rest of our experience. The service was excellent, and our server—a strikingly charismatic individual—helped us select a Cabernet and a fruity white wine, both of which were fantastic. The food was outstanding, arriving surprisingly quickly despite the complex layers of seasoning and flavor. Everything was perfectly prepared and a true pleasure to enjoy. We shared the ravioli, eggplant pasta, and a vibrant summer salad accompanied by jumbo shrimp—each dish was beautifully balanced and delicious. To finish, we had perfectly executed cannolis and espresso, which were indulgent without being overly rich. This was a truly memorable meal, and we’ll definitely be returning. Highly recommend! •H

A neighborhood gem. Great food theatre I how they prepare some of their fare at the table before serving. A rare treat for diners. Food and service were great.

Osteria Nonnino is truly a gem. The ambience is gorgeous, both the food and the service is excellent. We all had different pasta dishes, and each one was absolutely delicious! 

Butera's is a great restaurant food is always consistent and delicious! Staff is attentive and friendly !