Best Sicilian Restaurants in Short Hills

8 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Eataly Ristorante - Short Hills restaurant

1. Eataly Ristorante - Short Hills

new

3.6

Very Good(224)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Millburn

Booked 170 times today

While pizza and pasta are just the tip of the Italian iceberg, there is a reason these two culinary staples are the most beloved exports from Italy. Enjoy our seasonal selection just steps away from where our expert pasta chefs and dough-slinging pizzaioli (pizza makers) create dishes before your eyes.

2. Felina - Summit

4.3

Awesome(106)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • Summit

Booked 40 times today

Felina Summit extends the legacy of Felina Ridgewood and Felina Steak in Jersey City. Guests can indulge in elevated Italian comfort food prepared with modern techniques, showcased in a large scale open kitchen adorned with terrazzo and mosaic marble detailing. A floating kitchen hood adds a contemporary touch, while the restaurant’s grandeur dining room features a fireplace, a 60-seat bar featuring five signature negronis on tap, and a step-down dining area that enhances its inviting ambiance.

3. L'Allegria

4.4

Awesome(751)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Madison

Booked 5 times today

L'Allegria in Madison has firmly established itself as a pinnacle of dining excellence since its inception in 1984 by brothers Saverio and Giovanni Allocca. Celebrated for its authentic and meticulously prepared cuisine, L'Allegria offers a "quintessential Italian dining experience" that resonates well with both critics and diners alike. Guests consistently rave about the "fantastic" lobster and the "tender and flavorful" octopus, highlighting the restaurant's commitment to quality and authenticity. The ambiance, reminiscent of a Mediterranean courtyard, along with an "excellent" service, ensures that each visit is memorable. L'Allegria is truly a place "where flavor is the essence," making it a must-visit for anyone seeking an authentic dining experience.

A photo of Giorgio's Ristorante - South Orange restaurant

4. Giorgio's Ristorante - South Orange

4.9

Exceptional(483)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • South Orange

Giorgio's Ristorante in South Orange is a cherished destination for authentic Italian cuisine. Praised for its "real traditional homemade Italian food," this family-owned gem offers a menu filled with all-time favorites that keep patrons coming back. Customers rave about the perfectly al dente tortellini in Alfredo sauce, and the tiramisu that even skeptics find "EXCELLENT." The cozy ambiance and warm, welcoming service from the owner, Anthony, enhance every dining experience, making guests feel like part of the family. Whether it's a casual lunch or a celebratory dinner, Giorgio's consistently delivers high-quality Italian dishes with a personal touch that stands out in the community.

A photo of Taormina Ristorante restaurant

5. Taormina Ristorante

5.0

Exceptional(71)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • Union

Booked 3 times today

Since opening in 1998 by chef Salvatore Taormina, from Palermo, this cozy and unique Italian restaurant has been a gathering spot for many of friends and family. Chef Sal's Sicilian roots stand out in a variety of his dishes, some including; stuffed Artichoke, roasted Branzino and our famous Hotsy Totsy Shrimp. Complemented with a private room for large groups of up to 30. Bar and patio seating also available!

A photo of Calandras Italian Village restaurant

6. Calandras Italian Village

4.6

Exceptional(676)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Caldwell

Booked 26 times today

Calandra's Italian Village in Caldwell, NJ, offers a slice of authentic American dining with its rich array of Italian-inspired dishes that resonate deeply with American food lovers. Guests rave about the “homemade pastas” and the stone deck "wood burning oven" pizzas, highlighting the authentic quality and hearty flavors that define American comfort food with an Italian twist. Patrons consistently praise the restaurant for its “fantastic food” and the ambiance that makes every dining experience memorable. Whether it’s the “deliciously seasoned” pasta flight or the “flavorful” Polenta and meatballs, Calandra’s Italian Village stands out as a culinary gem. With glowing testimonials like “the best Italian restaurant in NJ,” and “amazing ambiance,” it’s clear why this spot remains a beloved choice for locals and visitors alike.

7. Ferraro's

4.9

Exceptional(644)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Westfield

Booked 2 times today

Ferraro's in Westfield has been a cornerstone of authentic Italian cuisine since 1969, renowned for its dedication to freshness and quality. The family-run ethos shines through in their traditional dishes like Sausage Lasagna and Cannelloni, which have delighted patrons for decades. Diners rave about their experiences, noting, "Every dish is a testament to the chef's skill and dedication to quality," and "Nonna’s meatballs...are worth a visit." With a blend of classic and contemporary Italian flavors, Ferraro's excels in both food and service, making it a must-visit for those seeking a genuine Italian dining experience.

A photo of Grano Italian Tavern restaurant

8. Grano Italian Tavern

4.4

Awesome(227)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Scotch Plains

Booked 13 times today

Grano Pizzeria & Italian Tavern specializes in classic Italian dishes, hand tossed pizzas, a comfortable bar atmosphere and catering for holidays and special occasions.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

P
PatrickVIP
San Francisco Bay Area •1 review
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
Hidden gem! Food delicious, cozy, great service! Would go back!
More info
Piccola Cucina Osteria - Spring St.Price: Expensive• Italian• SoHo
•
4.7
W
Wesley
Columbus •4 reviews
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
My wife and I always travel for Christmas and we love Italian dining. We do our best to find the most authentic, charming places we can. Typically these are going to be the places that seat 50 people and you may not think about going in. We’ve ate at multiple spots in Chicago, Indianapolis, Atlanta, Columbus, Cincinnati, Charleston, Alexandria… this is our new favorite! My goodness is was amazing! The staff was on top of it and soooo friendly. Our waiter, Gabriel was extraordinary! We legit felt like we were in Sicily. If you make one reservation in New York, make it here.
More info
Piccola Cucina EstiatorioPrice: Moderate• Italian• SoHo
•
4.7
K
KariVIP
New York City •23 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
Osteria Nonnino is truly a gem. The ambience is gorgeous, both the food and the service is excellent. We all had different pasta dishes, and each one was absolutely delicious!
More info
Osteria NonninoPrice: Expensive• Italian• West Village
•
4.6
C
CarmenVIP
Washington, D.C. Area •42 reviews
5.0
Dined on Dec 13, 2024
There’s nothing better than a great Jersey Italian restaurant and Taormina Ristorante was just that. Everything was perfect from beginning to end. Will definitely come back when in N J
More info
Taormina RistorantePrice: Expensive• Italian• Union
•
5

Explore OpenTable

Short Hills

Sicilian

Best Sicilian Restaurants in Short Hills

Price

Regions

Neighbourhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

8 restaurants available nearby

1. Eataly Ristorante - Short Hills

2. Felina - Summit

3. L'Allegria

4. Giorgio's Ristorante - South Orange

5. Taormina Ristorante

6. Calandras Italian Village

7. Ferraro's

8. Grano Italian Tavern

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable