Best Steak Restaurants in East Setauket

Absolutely my hands down number one go to for a fabulous meal and consistent service ALWAYS!!!! Highly recommend if you’re looking for that reliable kind of place! ALWAYS TOP NOTCH!

Lobster dinner for $55 included a fabulous choice of appetizers, I chose the Greek salad. We were given two baskets of bread with butter and olive oil. The 2 lb lobster was delicious, stuffed with crab meat and scallops. The asparagus looked great but had no taste. Dessert included, they had run out of Carmel tartufo but substituted regular tartufo and pistachio tartufo which was excellent, they also offered rice pudding annd chocolate mouse cake. Our server was oustanding! He was attentive but not over bearing, excellent service and very pleasant. One of the best servers we have ever had at Spiros. Totally recommend this restaurant and the Monday night lobster special!

The salad bar offered a large and varied assortment of salad, cheese, and protein. The meat selection offered at the table was delicious and varied, as well. Cocktails and desserts were beyond expectation

I truly enjoyed my date night at Insignia. Thank you Amir GM for the warm welcome. Kudos to the chef and team on the food, that Australian sirloin wagyu might just be the best steak I ever had. A special thanks to Erica and Stephen for their friendly and professional service, and also the food runner Ric (I think, I’m sorry) for serving out dinner so kindly. Also, Ivander and Matt from the valet team were awesome. Thank you all again!

The food is always amazing here. The petit filet Oscar style was very good. The sweet potato casserole is so delicious, no other restaurant has anything that can compare! Dylan our server did a fantastic job, tending to our every need. He suggested the champagne toast which was a very romantic touch. The bread, which some restaurants charge for, was fresh and warm; they replenished it 3 times. Dylan wrapped our leftovers for us.