Best Steak Restaurants in Nutley

Food was some of the best steakhouse food I’ve ever had, so much flavor and great ambiance

Celebrating birthdays at Mastro’s has become a cherished tradition for my wife and me, and this year was no exception for her special day. As always, Mastro’s delivered impeccable service and unparalleled food quality. It’s hands down my favorite steakhouse in New York City!

It’s always an absolutely fine experience whenever we dine at Ruth Chris! All I have to say negatively is, the amount of food has been reduced to 2/3 of what it use to be! And, of course the prices has increased 1/3, so in the long run you are paying much more for much less. The view is always nice. Nevertheless, our annual experience is always a happy one.

Great experience, food was excellent, service was good, noise level is a bit too much, had to yell to hear each other. But otherwise we loved the experience. Our fav dish- the tartare, followed by the truffle mushroom pasta, the waygu flight of three, and the hit me chocolate cake, in that order. Would go back again.

Review for Nuts-et Steak House Last night, my wife and I had the pleasure of dining at Nuts-et Steak House, and the experience was nothing short of extraordinary. The ambiance was warm and inviting, perfect for a romantic evening. The food was absolutely spectacular. Every dish was crafted with precision and packed with flavor. The steak, cooked to perfection, was tender and juicy, while the sides complemented the main course beautifully. Their attention to detail and quality ingredients truly elevated the dining experience. The service was equally impressive—attentive, professional, and friendly without being intrusive. They made sure every aspect of our evening was flawless. Sharing such a remarkable culinary experience with my beautiful wife made it even more special. Nuts-et Steak House is a gem, and we can't wait to return. Highly recommended!