Best Traditional Mexican Restaurants in Carnegie Hill

20 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Toloache - Upper East Side restaurant

1. Toloache - Upper East Side

4.8

Exceptional(1627)

Price: Expensive

• Traditional mexican • Upper East Side

Booked 30 times today

Toloache, located in the Upper East Side, New York, is a gem for lovers of Contemporary Mexican cuisine. As exquisitely noted by one patron, Toloache is "a Mexican restaurant a whole level above the usual," where Chef Julian Medina dazzles with his innovative use of natural ingredients and an array of chilies. The menu, featuring standout items like shredded duck with tamarind sauce and the unique quinoa truffle paella, has been consistently praised for its "explosion of flavors." Customers rave about the "melt-in-your-mouth" tacos and the enchanting Toloache crunch cake with chocolate pop rocks, enhancing every dining experience with a touch of magic. With its cozy and elegant ambiance, Toloache promises not just a meal, but a delightful culinary adventure in the heart of New York.

2. Toloache-Midtown

4.6

Exceptional(7644)

Price: Moderate

• Traditional mexican • Theater District

Booked 38 times today

Toloache-Midtown, located in the vibrant heart of New York's Theater District, is a gem for contemporary Mexican cuisine. Chef-owner Julian Medina's creative mastery shines in dishes infused with seasonal ingredients and an impressive variety of chilies. Guests rave about the "best ceviche" and "delicious, authentic & perfectly seasoned" meals, highlighting favorites like the lobster tacos and the unique pumpkin black truffle creamy rice. The guacamole and ceviche bar, alongside a wood-burning oven, adds a special touch to the dining experience. Reviews consistently praise the "outstanding food and service," making Toloache-Midtown a must-visit for a spellbinding Mexican culinary adventure.

3. Sinigual - NY

4.4

Awesome(2781)

Price: Moderate

• Traditional mexican • Midtown East

Booked 37 times today

Sinigual, a Manhattan favorite since 2008, offers modern Mexican cuisine just three blocks from Grand Central. Indulge in farm-fresh dishes like our tableside guacamole and handcrafted margaritas, all served in the heart of NYC. Join us for our Weekday Happy Hour, Taco Tuesday, & Weekend Brunch with Tableside Mimosa Buckets.

A photo of Dos Caminos - Lexington Avenue restaurant

4. Dos Caminos - Lexington Avenue

4.0

Excellent(106)

Price: Moderate

• Traditional mexican • Midtown East

Booked 14 times today

Welcome to Dos Caminos Lexington! Join the fiesta at one of New York City’s original Mexican restaurants! Dos Caminos features an expanded menu of authentic Mexican dishes as well as an extensive selection of premium tequilas and delicious, innovative cocktails. Experience the multi-regional modern cuisine for lunch, dinner and weekend brunch.

5. La Palapa

4.5

Awesome(868)

Price: Moderate

• Traditional mexican • East Village

Booked 9 times today

La Palapa, nestled in the vibrant East Village of New York, is renowned for its authentic Mexican cuisine, crafting "Mexico City style" tacos and quesadillas that transport your taste buds straight to the heart of Mexico. Patrons rave about the "amazing salsas" and the "best authentic food" in the city, highlighting dishes like Tacos al Pastor and Mole Negro Oaxaqueno. The restaurant's atmosphere is described as warm and friendly, making it a neighborhood favorite for nearly 20 years. Their award-winning Margaritas, made with fresh juices and a unique chile-piquin salted rim, are a must-try. As one reviewer puts it, La Palapa is "still so consistent and delicious," making it the go-to spot for genuine Mexican flavors in NYC.

6. Maz Mezcal

4.7

Exceptional(7)

Price: Expensive

• Traditional mexican • Upper East Side

Booked 9 times today

Located on the Upper East Side, Maz Mezcal has served authentic Mexican cuisine for over 38 years. Owner Mary Silva is delighted to continue her family's tradition of offering guests flavorful fare and wonderful service. Fajitas, seafood dishes such as paella and ceviche, and a large vegetarian & taco selection offer an array of options. Maz Mezcal features the UES largest agave tequila & mezcal selection, as well as a curated wine list from Mexico & South America.

7. Mole West Village

4.4

Awesome(82)

Price: Moderate

• Traditional mexican • West Village

Booked 6 times today

At Móle West Village in the heart of New York's bustling West Village, you'll experience Tex-Mex cuisine that dazzles and delights. Renowned for its authentic and sumptuous dishes, Móle offers everything from "Mexico City style shrimp ceviche that was to die for" to "superb brisket tacos" that keep patrons coming back. The "irresistible tableside guacamole," prepared fresh right before your eyes, embodies the restaurant's commitment to freshness and quality. Not just a treat for the palate, Móle features a cozy atmosphere and a "terrific outdoor seating" area, perfect for enjoying up to 125 varieties of tequila. According to one glowing review, "The cocktails are fire - perfectly crafted," making Móle not just a meal but an experience. A must-visit for anyone craving genuine Tex-Mex in NYC!

A photo of El Paso Mexican Restaurants East Harlem restaurant

8. El Paso Mexican Restaurants East Harlem

4.3

Awesome(9)

Price: Expensive

• Traditional mexican • East Harlem

El Paso Mexican Restaurants in East Harlem has been serving the best Mexican food in New York City & East Harlem for over 15 years. El Paso Mexican Restaurants, is recognized as one of the best Mexican restaurants in the country.It features classic regional Mexican cuisine prepared with authentic recipes and fresh ingredients. We invite you to come and enjoy a unique traditional Mexican experience in a friendly atmosphere.

9. Tortaria

4.0

Excellent(107)

Price: Moderate

• Traditional mexican • Union Square

Booked 1 time today

Tortaria, in the Union Square neighborhood of New York City, crafts specialty Mexican sandwiches and celebrates tequila cocktails in its bright and modern eatery outfitted with retro knickknacks. Tortaria’s main bill of fare is tortas, traditional Mexican sandwiches on fresh baked, ciabatta-like bread. Some of the most popular varieties include the slow-roasted pulled pork with Chihuahua cheese, avocado, roasted chipotle peppers and pickled onion, the panko-crusted chicken Milanesa with spicy black beans, Oaxaca cheese, chipotle mayo and cilantro and the torta beef burger, piled high with mozzarella, piloncillo tomatoes, jalapenos and chipotle mayo. Rolled and deep fried taquitos are the other staple at Tortaria, with flavors such as carne asada with tomatillo salsa and mahi lime tacos with citrus jalapeno remoulade being crisp and fresh choices.For a unique house cocktail, enjoy the house margarita with Conquistador tequila, triple sec, agave, and lime.

A photo of Pico De Gallo Bar & Kitchen restaurant

10. Pico De Gallo Bar & Kitchen

4.5

Awesome(23)

Price: Moderate

• Traditional mexican • Upper West Side

Pico de Gallo Bar & Kitchen, a Mexican restaurant, with a unique approach to the traditional Mexican food.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

P
Penny
New York City •5 reviews
5.0
Dined 4 days ago
We always look forward to our trip into the city for the amazing food , drinks and service. So good! Thank you!
More info
La PalapaPrice: Moderate• Mexican• East Village
•
4.5
J
JonathanVIP
Washington, D.C. Area •19 reviews
5.0
Dined 7 days ago
Mole is the sort of place you seek out in Mexico: Small, run by people who love it, based on traditional family recipes and ways. And it is aptly named. Mole is the acid test for a Mexican restaurant because it is hard to get right and when it is, it's fantastic. So was the mole at Mole, a sauce apparently prepared in Mexico and flown in. Not the spiciest I've ever had, but complex in the way mole should be. Don't miss it.
More info
Mole West VillagePrice: Moderate• Mexican• West Village
•
4.4
J
JedVIP
New York City •2 reviews
5.0
Dined on Dec 13, 2024
This is a go-to for me and my family. The kids love the fresh made guacamole and the elotes. The birria tacos are downright amazing, and a staple every time we come. Never a disappointing experience for us, looking forward to our next visit!
More info
El Asadero Mexican Grill - Rochelle ParkPrice: Moderate• Mexican• Rochelle Park
•
4.2
R
Richard
New Jersey •1 review
5.0
Dined on Nov 20, 2024
Took a chance for a last minute anniversary dinner. Great choice! Unbelievably creative cocktails, very attentive after, and really interesting Mexican menu. Taco appetizers were good, but the other dishes - mole enchilada and guava paste tostada - were exceptional. And the cocktail were so good we skipped dessert to indulge in one more round. Great little gem (in a funny strip mall). Highly recommend.
More info
Bitol Mexican Kitchen & Handcrafted Cantina HomePrice: Expensive• Mexican• Clifton
•
4.7
G
gtammaroVIP
New York City •45 reviews
5.0
Dined on Jul 24, 2024
Will miss my favorite Mexican restaurant! Best Mole Poblano!
More info
Mexico LindoPrice: Expensive• Mexican• Kips Bay
•
4.7

Explore OpenTable

Carnegie Hill

Traditional mexican

Best Traditional Mexican Restaurants in Carnegie Hill

Price

Regions

Neighbourhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

20 restaurants available nearby

1. Toloache - Upper East Side

2. Toloache-Midtown

3. Sinigual - NY

4. Dos Caminos - Lexington Avenue

5. La Palapa

6. Maz Mezcal

7. Mole West Village

8. El Paso Mexican Restaurants East Harlem

9. Tortaria

10. Pico De Gallo Bar & Kitchen

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable