Best Date Night Restaurants in Marco Island

Finn's Restaurant offers an exceptional dining experience from start to finish. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, with elegant decor that sets the perfect tone. The service is top-notch—attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable. The food is simply outstanding. The crispy calamari appetizer was delicious, and the seared scallops main course was cooked to perfection, with a rich, creamy risotto that complemented it beautifully. My companion’s grilled steak was equally impressive, perfectly seasoned and tender. The wine selection is excellent, and the chocolate lava cake for dessert was the ideal sweet finish. Whether for a special occasion or a casual meal, Finn's delivers an unforgettable experience. Highly recommend!

This was such a gem. I booked it weeks before Christmas and knew little about it. The reviews looked good so I went with it. They were able to accommodate more people when we had surprise visitors and the service and food were outstanding . A very enjoyable experience.

Our server, sorry can’t remember her name but a lovely young Serbian girl, was amazing!! Quick, attentive & very, very good at her job! All of the staff made us feel very welcome. Food was great with one small exception that was totally my fault. I ordered the tuna tataki & failed to notice that the description stated black pepper & somehow I read black sesame seeds. After I trimmed the edges my problem was solved. Note to chef, too much pepper for such a lovely piece of fish! Overall, a great time was had by all & we will be back.

We spent Christmas Eve here and it was magical. The service, food and ambiance were excellent. They adjusted the prix fixe price for our light eaters. The chocolate dessert even had gold shavings! Oh and the view! It was fantastic!

We had an outstanding birthday dinner at Tesoro. The hostess was so welcoming and friendly. Our waitress, Theresa, was sweet and professional. Our apps, meal and desserts were delicious. Beautiful presentation. Our table overlooked the sunset. Thank you!! We’ll be back.