Best Family Style Restaurants in Tenafly

Excellent food, generous portions, Been here several times, you MUST try the stuffed Artichokes.

Marianna was very friendly and attentive. We would request her again.

On this visit, a Tuesday, I enjoyed the half-price oyster offer with a full dozen. That was followed by the lamb shank. I requested a different accompaniment—pappardelle instead of orzo—and this was done, no problem. Delicious! As always, the experience was enjoyable. I went early in the evening to enjoy the peaceful atmosphere. If you’re there late on Thursday through Saturday, you’re in for some raucous partying. So choose accordingly.

My husband and I went to That Supper Club on Valentine's Day and had a fantastic time! Everything was just perfect. The food, ambiance, attention to detail, and sense of feeling taken care of and right at home at the same time was unmatched. The staff is outstanding! So warm and welcoming, while taking us on a journey of the courses is a wonderful experience. The courses were absolutely delicious and perfectly spaced out. We love not feeling rushed and we never felt that way at The Supper Club, which allowed us to truly enjoy our night out. It really is a beautiful experience and we cannot say enough about it. We love that the menu changes periodically which will allow us to have a whole other experience the next time we go, which we definitely will!

If you like Colombian food, then you'll love this place. We enjoyed well done chicharrón, chorizo, rice, beans, maduros, a perfectly fried whole fish - red snapper, tostones, and a variety of other dishes. While it can get quite crowded, the food and drinks are worth it. I had a passion fruit mojito that was delicious,and also tried the red sangria, which stood out as one of the best I’ve had, even compared to other Colombian and Cuban spots.