Best Fine Dining Restaurants in Nyack

Benjamin’s is by far our favorite restaurant in Westchester. We done there a few times a month, and always celebrate special occasions there. All of the staff treats you as if you are family. One of the many amazing waiters, Granite has memorized each of our drink and food orders. The food is also amazing and no other steakhouse in Westchester can compare. Always an amazing experience at Benjamin’s.

Need to put price per pound on the ice fish display

Our group of 14 was there to celebrate a family birthday. We were seated in a comfortable space, service was attentive and thoughtful, and everything went off in a timely way without being rushed. The food was quite good and arrived hot, which can be tricky with a party this size. Nora was our server, and she and the others who helped at our table were efficient and personable. Quick PS. On review, I see that we were charged a $42 cake plate fee for serving my brother's birthday cake. This was not mentioned when I brought the cake in even though I approached the server alone and it would have been a perfect time to tell me. Just be aware and ask questions because you will not necessarily be told about extra fees.

Our first visit was exceptional! The decor and ambiance was outstanding, as was the service, drinks, and food. Although it was a busy Saturday night, the noise level was very low, enabling us to have conversations in a normal tone. The Sparkill Steakhouse checks all of the boxes that you look for in a fine dining establishment. We highly recommend this restaurant, and will definitely visit many times again.

We just returned after many years - what an amazing place - great service, great wine menu, great food. HIGHLY recommend.