Best Restaurants with Private Rooms in New Castle

Had an amazing time for our first experience at The Back Burner. Diana was quick to ask if it was our first time & once we said it was she talked us around the menu. Telling us that they sell crazy amounts of the “better cheddar”, you get a great amount of flatbread which has a homemade pita chip vibe. We had the crab bisque which was so good my fiancé almost forgot to share any with me! We split the wedge salad, which was so refreshing. He got the short rib and I got the salmon Wellington. We had to get all that bagged up so we could try out some dessert. We got the raspberry crème brûlée, it was so tasty.

It was the night before Valentines Day it was super crowded but they handled everything so well! Everyone stepped in to help including hostesses, waitstaff, bartenders and Managers to clean tables and move. Hairs around bring food out whatever it took. We took a seat in the bar area and gave up our reservation for people waiting. It was fun!

Great food and service. Food was hot and our waitress very attentive and prompt. Overall fabulous experience as we have experienced before. This is always a favorite choice for his birthday celebration.

Had a FANTASTIC 21st birthday dinner for our daughter here. What a great way to celebrate - great service, fantastic food and drinks, and gelato!!! Thanks Cafe Gelato for making the celebration a WONDERFUL TIME!

Service was great when the waitress actually showed up. Menu was odd but what we ordered we liked. Would have ordered more after apps if our waitress ever returned. We called it a night and went to grab wings. Good concept poor execution.