Best Comfort Food Restaurants in Hutchinson Island

We received superb service. The food was wonderful.

Our entrees were excellent. Chicken thighs were so good, and the salmon (I had it blackened), was very good. Service was great; attentive but not overbearing. Our server Megan was helpful and extremely friendly and very knowledgeable. We highly recommend B. Matthew’s.

Was able to get an early dinner reservation at The Pirates’ House on Valentine’s Day. My husband ordered the pasta special and I had the pecan glazed chicken they are famous for. Both dishes were delicious. Tom was our server and he was attentive and efficient. I would definitely come back to The Pirates’ House again when I’m in town.

Ate here on Valentine’s Day. It was a little bit cold and windy, but still, you can’t beat the view from the roof and we had a very pleasant experience. The bouf bourginon special was Outstanding. Mostly small plates otherwise. Tasty cocktails and excellent service (thanks Jill!) Would recommend to others.

We enjoyed ourselves. For a restaurant that is a higher tier menu, we did find it odd that they have two giant screen TVs playing sports where it just didn’t seem to fit the vibe otherwise of the very nice dining ambiance. Our server was incredibly personable and helpful with helping us pick the best meal.