Best Date Night Restaurants in Coral Bay

Beautiful table at sunset. Our table of four hot prime rib, chicken, sea bass, and snapper, all very good. Our waiter Brandon was very efficient, responsive and super friendly. We really enjoyed our experience!

I cannot begin to describe how incredible this place is. The service, the food, the drinks. We tried the Foccacia, the Meatballs and the Calamari for appetizers. All were wonderful, but the meatballs are to die for! My son had Alfredo with Chicken, and they allowed him to swap penne for fettuccini. All the pasta is homemade and delicious! His friend had Chicken Francese and they allowed him to swap the polenta for linguini. And I had the Snapper Piccata as a recommendation from our server….it was amazing! I would have loved to try dessert but we could barely walk out of the place we were all so full. We are visiting during the holidays and they had a nicely decorated Christmas tree in the dining room, which made us feel at home. If you’re expecting an open-air environment like so many places are in St. Thomas, this isn’t like that. It’s more of an upscale but comfortable vibe and the A/C is effective, so you may want a light sweater or jacket. What made the experience even better than the food and the ambience, was the service. It was apparent that everyone there wanted us to enjoy ourselves and went above and beyond to make that happen. We loved Pesce so much we plan to return before we depart to go home.

Amazing experience. The bartender was superb! He had the best vibe and made the experience so much better! The food was amazing!

We had a fabulous, authentic, island time meal & drinks. Our party of five adults chose to order all of the starters for our dinner and they were delicious. Group favorites- the fritters, caramelized plantains, spicy shrimp, fried chicken. We appreciated that the staff was friendly and we weren’t rushed through our meal. The rum balls were a perfect ending to the meal. Try the rum flight and the El Presidente for beverages.

We sat outside overlooking the water. Our waitress, Charlotte, was excellent and very familiar with the menu offering suggestion of her favorites and most ordered. I had the Caribbean lobster which was excellent. My husband had the sea bass. Bread service was not included but homemade and very good.