Best Restaurants for Quiet Conversation in City Island

This is our favorite local restaurant. Took my husband for his birthday. We shared butternut squash soup and a bistro salad. I got the halibut special and my husband got the stuffed shrimp special. This place is always fantastic from its food, to drinks, to specials, service and ambiance.

Food excellent especially home made pastas. Staff are all great. Excellent experience

Lefkes is an absolute gem! From the moment we walked in, the staff went above and beyond to make us feel welcomed and cared for. Their warm hospitality and attention to detail truly made our dining experience exceptional. Each course was perfectly timed, and they were always nearby, ensuring our glasses were full and that we had everything we needed. The team's knowledge of the menu and their recommendations were spot on, adding to the overall enjoyment. Lefkes has set a high standard for service—I can’t recommend it enough!

Great place to meet friends for delicious food and comfortable atmosphere!!

Love this place! Wines are organic so no headache. They do need a piece of fish on the menu and another salad choice.