Best Restaurants with a Fireplace in Millstone Township

This was my second visit to Istanbul Bay and as with the previous time, the food was delicious, the service was top notch and the ambiance was wonderful

Cant wait to come back and try other menu items! TThe Caesar salad was one of the bets I’ve had: light, so tasty, loved the egg in the middle. The beet salad was great, loved the ricotta The scallops were outstanding - perfectly cooked & loved the nuts and broth. The spicy rigatoni was good but too heavy. I could only eat a few bites and had to take it wrapped. The olive oils cake was really tasty and I loved that the cake was moist but it said sticky toffee sauce, which I don’t think it had. I wish it did and wish it was warm, that would have been a nice addition. The pistachio gelato was delicious. Highly recommend. The service was good too :) thanks. Will be back.

This place is a must. It’s a beautiful restaurant with rustic and modern to give you perfect ambience. Staff is like family. They remember you always and that’s something you don’t find everywhere. Food amazing. So many choices enough to make you return. So delicious. We ordered the Big Jumbo Scallops they were perfect. Rigatoni (GF) Chicken n Shrimp. Our friends had the Sunday Sauce and the Zuppa di Pesce. Their first time and will be returning. We had a great time!!! Thanks see you again soon.

Very busy on Valentine’s Day, but they handled it well! We waited at the bar and had a drink before our table was ready. We sat upstairs where it was quiet and very pretty! Great service, delicious food (we had the surf & turf special), and took our dessert home as the food portion was quite large. Also, Shray in the liquor store portion of the establishment was very knowledgeable and so kind. Looking forward to our next visit!