Best Restaurants for Handcrafted Cocktails in Fisher Island

This was my third visit to Santorini in the past three weeks! I love taking friends as so many dishes are ideal for sharing! Last night our dishes included the mixed grill plate (steak, chicken and lamb with French Fries and Pita, as well as the beautiful grilled vegetable plate - drizzled with balsamic is was a colorful platter. Portion sizes are large, so the value is very good (especially for South Beach / South if Fit). Indoor and outdoor seating options are available, the latter around the pool. Yes, this restaurant is physically located in the Hilton Bentley Beach, but it’s not a typical “hotel restaurant”. There’s often live music and on this Saturday there was also a Middle Eastern dancer. I do ask for a table away from the music, as while it adds a nice touch, I still want to be able to have conversation. My last two visits my server was Danny. He’s so welcoming, explains and highlights menu options (I’ve usually ordered the Chicken Kababs, and tried the Mixed Grill on his recommendation. While a team serves you, as things come from the kitchen, Danny checked back in with us. Finally, this is a very small item, but the To Go Boxes, in my case for leftovers (I told you portions are large), are sone of the best I’ve seen. They have three sections, so you can separate a salad from entree from Pita, etc. So glad that Santorini’s is just a few blocks from me, as it’s a great place to take friends! FYI on weekdays they offer a Happy Hour with a small plates menu.

Incredible Service at Nikki Beach! We had an amazing experience at Nikki Beach, and a huge part of that was thanks to Gabriel! From the moment we sat down, he was attentive, sociable, and genuinely kind. His great sense of humor and friendly personality made our visit even more enjoyable. He went above and beyond to ensure we had everything we needed, and his positive energy was truly contagious. Gabriel is the kind of server who makes a lasting impression, and we can’t wait to come back. Highly recommend asking for him if you visit—he’s the best!

Our dining experience at this steakhouse has great! The dining room was eclectic yet still nice! It’s a truly unique spot! The service great with ample staff to assure your water stays filled and dirty plates cleared quickly. Our 24oz bone in rib eye steak was perfectly seasoned and more than enough for two to share! Definitely a go to spot if you want to impress!

Amanda, our server, has a gift for making you feel special even when she’s balancing ten tables. Natalia at the front desk also deftly juggles groups waiting as well as anyone I’ve ever seen. Both are keepers!

Our server wasn’t great but food was amazing and the ambiance was stellar!! The server has some learning to do when working in a higher priced restaurant.