Best Seasonal Restaurants in Mt. Sinai

Beautiful table with reservations on open table. Guacamole portion was small

Dinner and service was great food came out as we ordered in a timely fashion and our server was truly attentive. Looking forward to coming back again thank you

Wow—Sandbar absolutely blew us away! We stopped in for dinner and were lucky enough to try two incredible off-menu dishes that NEED to become permanent staples. The short rib tacos were hands down some of the best we’ve ever had—rich, tender, and packed with flavor. If these aren’t on the menu soon, it would be a crime! Then there was the halibut special with coconut… just wow. Perfectly cooked, with a silky, tropical twist that made every bite unforgettable. This dish deserves a permanent place on the menu! To top it all off, our server Edwin was phenomenal—attentive, friendly, and made us feel right at home. We’re already counting down the days until our next visit. Sandbar, you’ve won us over!

After passing Cafe Testarossa for years, we finally decided to give it a try. It was so great! We were seated right away and given water, crusty bread, butter and bruschetta with olive oil on the side. All delicious and all the staff was so friendly and helpful. Our waiter, Stephen was very attentive and friendly. He brought us our drinks (very dry martini and glass of Pinot Noir) promptly and took our order. Farro salad and clams oreganata for appetizers was served quickly. Everyone on staff helps out and really hustles! Both appetizers were delicious. We asked for more bread and got it right away. Entrees were homemade spinach raviolis (buttery soft pasta, unbelievable!) and Orrechette with sausage in garlic and oil (also great!). We got more wine with dinner. For dessert, Stephen recommended the caramelized banana Napoleon. It did not disappoint! Some espresso with Sambucca and a cup of tea and we were stuffed. We brought home some shrimp and crab cakes for our daughter and she said they were great! The atmosphere is classy, but not stuffy at all and we cannot compliment the staff enough. We can't believe we took so long to find this hidden gem. It is our new favorite Italian restaurant!

From the first sip of my pear martini to the shrimp and calamar to the branzino it was a magnificent tongue sensation. The ambiance is fantastic with 3 different rooms for dining. Service with Sidney was warm, attentive and informative of the unique offerings. Excellent Experience!