Best Historic Restaurants in Plumsteadville

Dinner was perfect. Delicious menu options. Wonderful service. Beautiful setting and view.

We were there for an early Sunday supper. It was a surprise to get stone crab claw cocktail. Both my chicken croquette and my husband’s prime rib, princess cut were very, very delicious. The croquettes taste like how they would cook in Japan. The prime rib was quality meat and cooked just right. We also enjoyed the apricot walnut bread pudding. Our server, Airyn was very very knowledgeable about the dishes and gave us a thorough description of everything. The food was served fast enough surprisingly in a very busy restaurant. Overall, we were very happy.

Our go-to restaurant when we have friends and family visiting. The service is always excellent, the menu expansive enough for everyone to find something they like, and the choice between the more energetic historic section of the tavern or the quieter greenhouse area is really appreciated. Some menu favorites of ours... the pork schnitzel with mustard sauced potatoes, the bacon wrapped shrimp and calamari appetizers, and definitely the homemade rice pudding. A gem of a restaurant in an unlikely location that's worth the trip.

Bucks County needs a venue like Frost. Site is tiny which is great except when you are seated near loud, obnoxious guests. Prices are high, yes. But most reviews fail to understand that there is no cover or music charge. Cocktails are crafted perfectly. The tapas were outstanding, the main entree just ok. They recognized my wife's birthday which spoke volumes because it means they read the notes left for the restaurant which are usually overlooked. Nice work. Well worth a visit. We will return

The food is always excellent, with innovative twists. The service was great, the staff is always pleasant, and you're never rushed. Brunch today, but lunch, dinner, or just drinks, a trip to The Water Wheel is NEVER a disappointment!