Best Historic Restaurants in St. Augustine

Dawn was our server. She was excellent. The scallop appetizer was fabulous. My husband had the shrimp supreme and I had stuffed shrimp. Wow! They were so amazing. Oh and the bread pudding was delicious too! Highly recommend the Columbia!

Amazing dining experience! Food was incredible from start to finish. Onion Tartin and French onion soup were excellent to start off with. The Steak Au Poivre and the Wagyu NY Strip were cooked perfectly to temperature and delicious. We finished the night with the Lavender Crème Brûlée which was creamy and decadent. Amelia was an incredibly attentive and informative server which helped perfect the whole dining experience. Definitely a place not to be missed during your visit to St. Augustine!

This restaurant is beautiful. We understand they recently redecorated and it looks like a Moroccan scene with arched entryways and middle eastern style. A piano player fills the place with all types of music which is one reason you know you’re not in Algiers. The other is the fantastic menu items which were strongly American. We had a prime filet that was very tender and tasty and a two inch thick grouper that matched. The waitress had been there for four years and was able to cover her stations with easy. Always available and cheerful. This was a special occasion (birthday) and we were served a complimentary dessert. Wow! What a spectacular event for us!

Located right off of the main downtown area. Great ambiance, had online reservations for a group of 7 available which was awesome for our bachelorette party! We loved the menu/GF offerings and shoutout to our waitress for making the whole party feel special! We enjoyed the celebratory toast! I would happily recommend this location to others. The corn chowder and artichoke appetizer were delicious. The group also enjoyed the Bella chicken entree!

Overall, the food and chef's creations were excellent, truly fine dining. Service was excellent - well informed on the menu, had opinions on wine selection and were attentive during the evening. Definitely recommend. One detail - For dining at this level and expense - would think they would have a full liquor license.