Best Hot Spot Restaurants in Fisher Island

The mansion does not fail! It was beautiful like always! Great food and the staff (servers) were very very sweet. Especially our one server. The girls at the front can look a bit unfriendly, to the point that makes you a bit unwelcome but overall it was a beautiful Christmas Day at the Versace mansion. Maybe a little renovation on the chairs would be good too. It is price friendly (kinda) so in my opinion, the furniture should reflect the “luxury” look. At least a good cleanup. The food was really good, we had the spaghetti with lobster.. the burrata was amazing.. drinks pretty good.. no complaints at all! Thank you for making our Christmas 2025 beautiful all the way from Canada!

The hostess' treatment was rude, she was very impatient and spoke in a disrespectful tone, the treatment of the waiters was excellent, they gave us recommendations and the conversation with them was pleasant, but the service at the entrance leaves a lot to be desired

The restaurant left an exceptional impression on me. The food was simply delicious, with flavours that surprised my palate in every dish. The presentation of the food was also impeccable, which made the experience even more enjoyable. As for the service, the staff was attentive and friendly, always willing to recommend dishes and make sure we had everything we needed. Their professionalism really stood out and contributed to making the evening memorable. The ambiance of the restaurant was cosy and well decorated, creating a perfect space to enjoy a good meal. The soft lighting and background music complemented the experience, making me feel relaxed and content. All in all, it was an experience that exceeded my expectations and I will definitely be back.

We had an incredible experience at Milos on Christmas Eve! The food was absolutely amazing—every dish was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. The service was impeccable; the staff was attentive, friendly, and made us feel so welcomed. The ambience was perfect, with a warm and elegant atmosphere that made the meal even more special. I can’t wait to return and highly recommend Milos to anyone looking for a fantastic dining experience!

I have been to Stubborn Seed many times since learning about it two years ago. As excellent and noteworthy as the menu and service have typically been, last night was a step beyond. Literally, every item in the menu was interesting, beautifully presented, and having wonderful contrasts and subtleties. Really, a sublime experience.