Best Neighbourhood Gem Restaurants in Bethany Beach

We had the best experience! From the Charcuterie to the braised short ribs! Drinks and service were excellent! Overall a wonderful evening!

Charles always ensures we are warmly welcomed to the classic Blue Moon, and graciously accommodated the last minute addition of guests at our table. Kathryn provided fantastic service, learning everyone’s names at the table of 7. The Holiday Legends Show was fantastic - as the food always is! The Blue Moon is a local treasure!

Excellent dinner, Excellent service, Beautifully decorated for the holidays. It's good to know that there still is a 5star restaurant in CapeMay. A few of our favorite restaurants in Cape May have slipped in the past couple years especially with service. The Ebbitt Room hit every standard of excellence and they were open past 8pm!

I was so grateful that the Blue Pig Tavern honored my requests for seating by putting my partner and I at the table we hoped for, off in the corner of the room with the fireplace. The atmosphere is cozy, welcoming, and warm and everyone treated us so kindly. What a special anniversary dinner. (Also, the pumpkin pie with cranberry drizzle was one of the best desserts I've ever had).

One Coastal is my favorite restaurant, so, not surprisingly, our meal was wonderful. All of the items we ordered-that agrobay field greens and rockfish and catfish entrees- were excellent, the drinks were great and the service was flawless. It's our go-to restaurant whenever we're in the area and can get a reservation.