Best Neighbourhood Gem Restaurants in Shelter Island
Price
- $40 or less
- $41 to $65
- $65 or more
Cuisine
Regions
Neighbourhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility
4 restaurants available nearby
How is content generated
See what locals rave about
- WWilliamNew York City •9 reviews4.0Dined 1 day agoGreat value. Terrrific prime rib dinner! Service was friendly and efficient and we weren’t hurried.More infoSophie's Rest.Price: Moderate• American• Southold•4.7
- DDonaldNew York City •2 reviews5.0Dined 2 days agoEverything was absolutely excellent. And had an exsquisit bottle of wine on discounted wine Mondays which I was not aware of. I would recommend this for a very very nice dinner out for anyone.More infoJ. Gilbert’s – Wood Fired Steaks & Seafood – GlastonburyPrice: Expensive• Steak• Glastonbury•4.8
- OTOpenTable DinerNew York City •2 reviews5.0Dined 3 days agoEverything was delicious! Service, 6 courses of small plates and ambiance.More infoNoah'sPrice: Expensive• Tapas / Small Plates• Greenport•4.5
- DDianaConnecticut •1 review5.0Dined 7 days agoOur late lunch early dinner was fabulous on New Year's Day 2025. Our waitress, Barbara, was very friendly, energetic, helpful and wonderfully nice-she gets all the kudos for a great visit. We will definitely return to Fresh Salt.More infoFresh SaltPrice: Expensive• Seafood• Old Saybrook•4.6
- YYasminVIPNew York City •82 reviews5.0Dined on Dec 25, 2024Great holiday evening! Maria Paulis was fantastic! Professional, knowledgeable, attentive and kind. The food was great too.More infoVine Street CafePrice: Very Expensive• American• Shelter Island•4.6
Discover best neighborhood gem restaurants in Shelter Island
Discover the charm of Shelter Island's dining scene, where each restaurant shines as a "neighborhood gem" offering unique and delightful experiences. Shelter Island, a serene and picturesque locale in Suffolk, New York, boasts a variety of dining establishments that are perfect for both casual and sophisticated tastes. These restaurants are celebrated for their commitment to quality, with many emphasizing locally-sourced ingredients and inventive dishes that reflect the area's culinary diversity. Patrons can expect warm, inviting atmospheres coupled with service that's both attentive and personable, ensuring a memorable dining experience. Whether you're looking for a cozy spot for a romantic dinner or a friendly venue for a family gathering, Shelter Island's restaurants cater to all occasions with excellence and charm. The dining scene here is a testament to the community's passion for good food and genuine hospitality, making it a true destination for food lovers. Each restaurant not only meets the expectations of locals and visitors but also contributes to the island's reputation as a culinary haven in Suffolk.