Restaurants near Mystery Bay State Park

Great food, great service and wonderful experience

Awesome experience. Food for all of us was extraordinary. Service was warm, friendly and attentive. Highly recommend.

This is one legendary restaurant that lives up to its legend. The food is out of this world. The service is brilliant. The room with a view is spectacular and the room in the lounge is cozy. This is a go-to place for special occasions. Thank you to Jackie, Jeannie and the whole staff who greeted us and our special guest so warmly.

To be fair, it was a Monday evening on a chilly, blustery day so there was only one other occupied table besides us, making fir a very quiet atmosphere. We hadn't been to Alchemy in years, and I'm glad we came back. The service was just right, the dishes perfectly executed and we had an altogether pleasant evening. The Dungeness and bacon Alfredo was amazing! Definitely recommend as a cozy, intimate place, especially in the winter off-season.

Really, really special experience! We have dined (and stayed) here many times, but tonight’s Vivaldi Experience was truly special. The meal was stunning and so thoughtfully curated. The live music from the string quartet was magical. The service (as always) was warm and welcoming. Thank you so much!