Restaurants near Plymouth Church of Shaker Heights

Had a great dinner with a couple friends - delish food and the staff was all excellent & friendly. The ambiance was wonderful - cozy and well laid out. The right balance of feeling like you're somewhere fun and hip, but also could have private conversation - highly recommend!

Dining at Edwins is always a delight! My shared dinner with two dear friends was no exception. It began with seating. My friend commented on how cold the night air was and if we could sit where it would be cozy. The host scanned the room of diners and decided, with a brief consultation, to seat us in the private dining area. We had the curtained room to ourselves, but service to our remote table could not have been more accommodating! In search of a wine, the chef, John, pulled himself from a busy kitchen to offer a single bottle remaining from an event he had hosted earlier this season. It was a superb Saint-Estèphe. So began a memorable meal that started with foie gras, perfectly seared, tender, and served with roasted apples and Calvados sauce. Sublime. The salad was a croquet of goat cheese with crisp fresh greens, and our three dinners were grilled rabbit, grouper, and seafood sausage in lemon butter wine sauce. Everyone was pleased with their choice. The food, wine, and conversation flowed with unobtrusive and impeccable service and a warm visit from the restaurant impresario himself, Brandon Crostowski. We were too full to try the desserts and were honoring our New Year's resolutions. We hope to return soon and maybe start with dessert?

We drove from Columbus to visit this place. Worth the drive! We had a great time. With the interactive staff and laughs also some scares lol. Definitely a 5 star place if you like horror and jump scares with some laughs. Awesome time!

Amazing food and service! We will definitely be going back. Best restaurant we have been to in Little Italy. Reminded me of all the delicious food we had on our last trip to Italy.

Always a lovely meal and experience. They consistently go above and beyond.