Skip to main content

Home
United States
New York State

Best Southern American Restaurants in Fishers Island

Price

$$
$$$
$$$$

Regions

NassauSuffolk

Neighbourhoods

AmityvilleBabylonBellmoreCarle PlaceCold Spring HarborDeer Park

Top Rated

CharmingFancyGood for business mealsGood for groupsGood for special occasionsGreat for brunch

Dining Options

All dining options

Delivery only

Takeout only

Seating Options

BarCounterStandardHigh TopOutdoor

Accessibility

Gender-neutral washroomWheelchair access

78 restaurants available nearby

A photo of 317 Main Street restaurant

1. 317 Main Street

4.7

Exceptional(1701)

$$$$Price: Moderate

• Southern american • Farmingdale

Booked 6 times today

317 Main Street in Farmingdale offers an authentic American dining experience, showcasing the exceptional talent of Chef Eric LeVine, a two-time "Chopped" Champion. Known for his creativity and passion, Chef Eric expertly weaves local flavors into classic American grill dishes, creating a menu that is both innovative and comforting. Guests rave about the "delicious" food and "phenomenal" dining experiences, describing the atmosphere as fun and upbeat. Patrons appreciate the friendly and attentive staff, with standout service from servers like Janice. Whether enjoying a crafted cocktail or Chef Eric's inventive dishes, "317 Main Street" promises an unforgettable American culinary adventure.

A photo of HARLEYS American Grille restaurant

2. HARLEYS American Grille

4.5

Awesome(1095)

$$$$Price: Moderate

• Southern american • Farmingdale

Booked 9 times today

HARLEYS American Grille on Main Street in downtown Farmingdale is a beacon of outstanding Grill cuisine. Renowned for its exquisitely crafted dishes, diners rave about the "delicious meal" and "excellent service," with many highlighting the Porterhouse special and its impressive tableside fire show. The restaurant's commitment to authentic flavor and high-quality ingredients ensures that every bite is a memorable experience. Guests frequently commend the "friendly and attentive" staff and the lively yet welcoming atmosphere. With a menu offering mouthwatering options like ribeye eggrolls and steak frites, HARLEYS is a must-visit for those seeking a superior Grill dining experience.

A photo of The Halston restaurant

3. The Halston

4.5

Awesome(359)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• Southern american • Melville

Booked 16 times today

Discover the vibrant flavors of Contemporary American cuisine at The Halston in Melville, where legendary restaurateur Anthony Scotto crafts a dining experience that is both "approachable and lively." With a menu that offers an extensive array of culinary delights, from signature salads and hearty burgers to exquisite sushi and seafood, The Halston truly caters to every palate. Its warm ambiance and attentive service, praised as "outstanding" and "impeccable," ensure a memorable dining experience. Whether it's a business lunch, family dinner, or a special celebration, guests consistently rave about the "truly amazing" food and the inviting atmosphere that brings "FUN back to fine dining."

A photo of The Bryant restaurant

4. The Bryant

4.5

Awesome(1611)

$$$$Price: Very Expensive

• Southern american • Huntington

Booked 49 times today

The Bryant in Huntington is a shining star in the realm of Contemporary American cuisine, delivering an unparalleled dining experience with every visit. "Always a great meal, great atmosphere too," raves a satisfied patron, while others celebrate the "fresh salads, delicious burgers, and seafood" that highlight their diverse menu. The Bryant's commitment to quality and authenticity is evident in dishes like the halibut with asparagus and mushrooms, which are consistently praised for their incredible flavor. The vibrant atmosphere, coupled with "five-star" service, makes The Bryant a must-visit destination for anyone seeking the true essence of Contemporary American dining.

A photo of Rustic Root restaurant

5. Rustic Root

4.6

Exceptional(469)

$$$$Price: Moderate

• Southern american • Woodbury

Booked 23 times today

Rustic Root, nestled in the heart of Woodbury Village, is a shining example of authentic American cuisine, offering a delightful farm-to-table experience that stands out among the best. With a menu rich in fresh, seasonal ingredients, Rustic Root is praised for its "inventive food and outstanding service." Diners rave about the "best ever tasty entrees" and "yummy drinks" that create a perfect dining atmosphere. The restaurant's commitment to organic and local produce is evident in every dish, from their acclaimed crispy Brussels sprouts to the delectable pumpkin cheesecake. Rustic Root is truly a gem for anyone seeking the essence of American dining.

A photo of OHK Bar & Restaurant restaurant

6. OHK Bar & Restaurant

4.6

Exceptional(3396)

$$$$Price: Very Expensive

• Southern american • Huntington

Booked 20 times today

Experience Europe in America at OHK BAR & RESTAURANT at OHEKA CASTLE, and enjoy award-winning cuisine by Executive Chef Raed Jallad. Please be advised of our on-site policies:OHK does not permit decorations, centerpieces, flowers, balloons, music, lighting, vendors or any outside food including cakes. Your reservation is subject to change or cancellation at any time and for any reason. While you may request a specific table, we cannot guarantee it’s availability. The use of professional photography equipment and wedding attire is strictly prohibited. We reserve the right to refuse amateur or professional photography for any reason. Additionally, if an event is occurring at Oheka Castle, guests will be unable to tour the grounds and the mansion.OHK operates as a restaurant within Oheka Castle. For inquiries regarding catering events or parties, please contact Kelly Melius, Director of Sales, or for private dining at OHK Restaurant, please contact Daniel Forman, Restaurant Manager.

A photo of Palmer's American Grill restaurant

7. Palmer's American Grill

4.6

Exceptional(1066)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• Southern american • Farmingdale

Booked 3 times today

Palmer's American Grill in Farmingdale is a true gem for those seeking an authentic Steakhouse experience. Known for its “perfect cut of meat,” the restaurant consistently delivers outstanding dishes like the expertly cooked filet mignon and NY Strip. Diners rave about the “top quality flavor” of their steaks, which are cooked to perfection, set against a backdrop of a warm and inviting atmosphere. The restaurant’s attention to detail and friendly service make every visit a delight. With live entertainment and a lively ambiance, Palmer's is not just a meal, but an experience, making it a standout choice for steak enthusiasts.

A photo of Milleridge Inn restaurant

8. Milleridge Inn

3.9

Excellent(2022)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• Southern american • Jericho

Booked 12 times today

Step back in time and enjoy one of Long Island's oldest treasures.Featuring traditional American cuisine, our Restaurant provides Lunch and Dinner service daily. Sunday features our Grand Brunch Buffet including unlimited lobster, shrimp, Nova Scotia salmon, and traditional brunch specialties.After you've enjoyed your meal at the Historic Milleridge Inn, be sure to take a stroll through our quaint village, which resembles Long Island Beginnings with a bakery, general store, and so much more. Please note: Reservations on OpenTable do not apply to the Cottage or special events.

A photo of Caracara Mexican Grill - Farmingdale restaurant

9. Caracara Mexican Grill - Farmingdale

4.4

Awesome(1441)

$$$$Price: Moderate

• Southern american • Farmingdale

Booked 10 times today

Caracara Mexican Grill in Farmingdale is a top-notch destination for authentic Mexican cuisine, offering a vibrant and welcoming atmosphere that makes it a favorite among locals. This upscale Mexican eatery is renowned for its "delicious table-side guacamole," "outstanding margaritas," and a "rich variety of traditional and innovative dishes," such as Iron Skillet Tacos and Pollo Relleno. Diners rave about the "always excellent food and a great experience," praising the restaurant's attentive service and flavorful entrees. With its extensive tequila selection and exciting daily specials, Caracara Mexican Grill promises a delightful culinary journey that transports guests straight to Mexico.

A photo of Sage Bistro Moderne - Woodbury restaurant

10. Sage Bistro Moderne - Woodbury

4.8

Exceptional(1266)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• Southern american • Woodbury

Booked 11 times today

Sage Bistro Moderne in Woodbury is a remarkable destination for authentic American cuisine, offering a delightful dining experience that keeps patrons coming back for more. "The food is consistently delicious," and the service is "excellent," making it a cherished spot for locals and visitors alike. The restaurant's inviting atmosphere complements its impressive menu, featuring standout dishes such as the "delicious Caesar salad" and "pecan-crusted chicken." Guests rave about the "spectacular food and service," praising the attentive waitstaff who enhance every visit. Sage Bistro Moderne's commitment to quality and authenticity makes it an ideal choice for anyone seeking a true taste of American culinary excellence.

1
2
3
…
8

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

From verified diners like you

A
anurag
New York City •15 reviews
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
What a delightful outing! I thought every dish impressed but none as much as the crab fried rice. From the chive work to the perfectly picked and sauteed MD crab, this dish hits! Our server, Isabel, was soulful and helpful. The only two notes we've have were that it was odd to receive the delicious broccolini way before everything else (twice actually as we loved it enough to order a second plate) and the Ramos Gin Fizz was just good, not great (Try one at Tooker Alley if you can).
More info
Strange DelightPrice: Expensive• Oyster Bar• Fort Greene
•
4.8
OT
OpenTable Diner
New York City •1 review
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
I called ahead to ask for the new award a Winning Weber Ranch Vodka. When I ordered it, the server remembered it was me and brought me a great tasting mule.
More info
Freebird Kitchen and BarPrice: Moderate• American• White Plains
•
4.7
E
EdwardVIP
New York City •21 reviews
5.0
Dined on Jan 26, 2025
Food and service excellent would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone for brunch
More info
Jackson's EateryPrice: Moderate• Contemporary American• Long Island City
•
4.6
S
Shanna
New York City •2 reviews
5.0
Dined on Jan 25, 2025
We love the Foundry. Service had some hiccups at the bar but our server was in communication with us. Had really good meals— everyone raved. Nice evening, thank you.
More info
Foundry Kitchen & TavernPrice: Expensive• American• Sandy Hook
•
4.5

Explore OpenTable

Neighbourhood
Cuisine nearby
Southern american cuisine

Fishers Island

Southern american

Nyack
Islip
White Plains
Mahopac
Nesconset
Pocantico Hills
Miller Place
East Quogue
Sea Cliff
Sag Harbor
Larchmont
St. James
Valhalla
Gilgo
New Hyde Park
Huntington
Chappaqua
Peekskill
Manhasset
Shelter Island

Discover

Dining Rewards
Reserve for Others
Restaurants near me
Delivery near me
Restaurants Open Now

OpenTable

About Us
Blog
Careers
Press

More

OpenTable for iOS
OpenTable for Android
Affiliate Programme
Contact Us

Our sites

OpenTable.com
OpenTable.jp
OpenTable.de
OpenTable.es
OpenTable.hk
OpenTable.ie
OpenTable.sg
OpenTable.nl
OpenTable.com.mx
OpenTable.co.uk
OpenTable.com.au
OpenTable.ae
OpenTable.co.th
OpenTable.it
OpenTable.com.tw
OpenTable.fr

Businesses

Delight more diners
Open for Business Blog

Join us on

Privacy Policy
Terms of Use
Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
Cookie Preferences

Copyright © 2024 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 500, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.

OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.