Best Restaurants for Outdoor Dining in Fishers Island

Me and My Girlfriend were just here tonight. We wanted to try a new place out so we chose Palmer’s. Honestly, it was one of the best full meals I have had at a restaurant. The Baked Clams, Caesar Salad, and Creamed Spinach were unreal. For our entrees, the rack of lamb was the best lamb I have ever eaten; she loved her chicken parm as well. If you love classic italian food done perfectly, Palmers is the place to go 1000%! The service was amazing from our Server and one of the owners even came to the table to see how everything was. The night ended with an unreal Tiramisu that really put the bow on it. 10/10 experience and we will absolutely be back here very soon!

From the moment we sat down Ken our waiter was full of life and energy. He didn't skip a beat. He was attentive and answered all our questions. EVERYTHING about him was awesome. My food was cold and I did mention it politely and he offered for my dish to be done over but i politely refused. I just wanted to let him know that i understood that the kitchen was probably swamped with orders, (hey stuff happens and I understand)....anyway he was very apologetic and the afternoon continued with a great dance party. I will say one thing, the volume of the music could def be turned down a decibel or two. Yes, we are there to dance, but when you have to scream at your friends during lunch just so they can hear you is a bit annoying. My throat hurt at the end of the afternoon. I am planning to come back and I hope the music is a bit better for the ears.

We were seated immediately upon arrival. The service was amazing as well as the food. Would highly recommend! The braised short rib special for Valentine’s Day was out of this world!

This is an update to a previous post where I gave a zero rating. I had the opportunity to dine here once again. Since my last dining experience, they hired a new General Manager to correct the issues they were having. While the food before was sub par there certainly has been a marked improvement and is excellent. The terrible service we had prior was a completed turn around. Juan and Lin treated us if we were family and royalty. Their attention not only to us but every other diner around us was impeccable. The new General Manager Joey came to the table several times making sure both the food and service was up to Scotto’s standards. My previous rating of zero is now a 5. Joey, Juan and Lin made sure our dining experience was top notch and an enjoyable evening both by the service and food. I will definetly go back.

Thursday night burgers and beers deal are a great night out.