Best Fine Dining Restaurants in Wallingford

Great dinner! We made 5:30 reservations. The hostess was very friendly. Our waitress was great (I wish I remembered her name) she knew the menu well and gave us great drink suggestions. We had the halibut and steak pasta for our meals. We can’t wait to return to try other meals.

Monica was our server and she was outstanding! Three of us done out monthly and we tried New Mill last night and was not disappointed!! I had the Maple Glazed Pork Chop and it’s cooked just right and was the best ever. The other entrees were crab stuffed cod and a home made cavatelli pasta with grilled chicken and those were also excellent. I topped off my meal with a slice of pumpkin cheesecake. Wow! Definitely going back!!

Great historical ambiance. Service was excellent and so was the food. Would definitely recommend and hope to be back soon.

The dry aged steaks were phenomenal! The flavor was perfection. The individual sides were very overpriced for the size they were 10 dollars each and it was just enough for one person. 10 bucks for a little mashed potato is a stretch in my opinion. The carrot cake was delicious and they make a mean espresso martini! The restaurant itself is gorgeous with a few stone fireplaces throughout and it’s very cozy.

My wife and I enjoyed a mouth-watering prime rib dinner in a quiet setting, served with perfect attentiveness to our needs. Each dish arrived at the very moment we were ready for it. We couldnt have been happier with our anniversary experience.