Best Italian Restaurants in Irvington

Went there for Valentine night, Please wear packed, Every single table was full, Easy Can tell why that busy, Food is excellent service is super attentive, Prices were fair!! See you guys soon

Sensational dining experience. The food was outstanding; particularly the salads, steaks and sides. Huge portions, quality ingredients, top-drawer preparation and all well-priced. The service was outstanding. We never felt rushed. All our questions were answered professionally, courteously and to our satisfaction. As for ambiance, the music was a bit too loud and monotonous, but, unlike most restaurants today, you could certainly carry on a conversation with no difficulty. All in all, we had a throughly great meal at One Rare. We will certainly return.

Food was delicious. I would request a table not near the kitchen door next time. Sitting in that section detracted from the experience.

This was the first time having pistachio flavored pasta (rigatoni in my case) and I was awesome. It was cooked with fennel and was absolutely delicious. My wife had the duck liver cannolli and she loved it as well. The service was excellent and attentive. Could not have had a better dining experience close to home!

This is my favorite restaurant of all! Anne Bell , south Nyack